This report provides a definitive, data-driven ranking of the Top 24 online firearm retailers in the United States. The analysis indicates that the market is not a simple monolith but is instead fragmented into four primary competitive clusters:

1. The Vertically Integrated Manufacturers: Retailers (e.g., Palmetto State Armory, Aero Precision) that manufacture their own core products, granting them unassailable advantages in price leadership and supply chain control.
2. The High-Volume Drop-Shippers: Aggressive, price-focused retailers (e.g., Dahlonega Armory) that leverage a capital-light, distributor-feed model. They compete entirely on price, often at the expense of customer service and fulfillment reliability.
3. The Niche Specialists: Retailers (e.g., EuroOptic, Classic Firearms) that have built defensible moats by specializing in high-margin or scarce product categories (e.g., premium optics, military surplus), making them immune to broad market price wars.
4. The Omnichannel Giants: Legacy brick-and-mortar retailers (e.g., Sportsman’s Warehouse, Cabela’s) that leverage their physical footprint as a key strategic advantage, primarily through in-store pickup, which eliminates the friction and cost of the FFL transfer process.

The final ranking is derived from a weighted model based on four key criteria: Market Share & Traffic (40%), Inventory Depth & Model (25%), Consumer Sentiment & Transaction Efficiency (25%), and Pricing Competitiveness (10%).

A. The Definitive Ranking of US Online Firearm Retailers

Note on Exclusions: As requested, Family Firearms has been excluded from this analysis as it is reportedly defunct.

Table 1: 2025 Top 24 Online Firearm Retailer Ranking (Weighted Score)

Rank	Retailer (URL)	Final Score (100)	Est. 12-Mo Avg. UMV (US)	Market Segment	Inventory Model	Trans. Efficiency Score (1-10)	Basket-of-Goods Avg. Price
1	Palmetto State Armory	94.5	8,500,000	Manufacturer	Vertically Integrated	9.0	$345.50
2	MidwayUSA	88.0	4,050,000	Generalist	Stocking Dealer	9.8	$368.75
3	Brownells	82.5	1,550,000	Specialist (Parts/Tools)	Stocking Dealer	9.5	$374.99
4	Primary Arms	81.0	1,540,000	Hybrid (Generalist/Mfg)	Hybrid (Stocking/Mfg)	9.2	$365.25
5	Guns.com	77.5	3,680,000	Marketplace (New/Used)	Marketplace	7.0	$385.00
6	GrabAGun	74.0	2,100,000	Deals / Volume	Hybrid (Stocking/Drop-Ship)	7.5	$349.99
7	Sportsman’s Warehouse	73.0	5,500,000	Generalist	Omnichannel	8.5 (In-Store: 10)	$379.99
8	EuroOptic	70.5	950,000	Specialist (Precision)	Stocking Dealer / Importer	9.9	$389.50
9	Classic Firearms	68.0	1,200,000	Specialist (Surplus)	Stocking Dealer / Importer	8.5 (Condition Accuracy)	N/A
10	Dahlonega Armory	65.5	1,800,000	Deals / Volume	Distributor Drop-Shipping	5.0	$338.50
11	Aero Precision	64.0	1,100,000	Manufacturer	Vertically Integrated	9.0	N/A (Sells 1/4 SKUs)
12	Kentucky Gun Co.	63.5	1,750,000	Generalist	Hybrid (Stocking/Drop-Ship)	6.5	$352.00
13	Bud’s Gun Shop	62.0	2,370,000	Generalist	Hybrid (Stocking/Drop-Ship)	6.0	$364.50
14	Atlantic Firearms	61.0	750,000	Specialist (Imports)	Stocking Dealer / Importer	8.8	N/A
15	Battlehawk Armory	58.5	650,000	Deals / Volume	Distributor Drop-Shipping	4.0	$339.00
16	Cabela’s	57.0	6,200,000	Generalist	Omnichannel	8.0 (In-Store: 10)	$399.99
17	Rainier Arms	56.0	500,000	Specialist (Tactical)	Stocking Dealer	8.5	$378.00
18	Gallery of Guns	55.5	800,000	Marketplace (Distributor)	Distributor Network	6.5	$370.00
19	Lanbo’s Armory	54.0	450,000	Deals / Volume	Stocking Dealer	7.0	$344.00
20	RifleGear	52.5	300,000	Specialist (Tactical)	Stocking Dealer	8.0	$375.50
21	AIM Surplus	51.0	400,000	Specialist (Surplus/Parts)	Stocking Dealer	7.5	$355.00
22	SMGA	49.0	350,000	Deals / Volume	Hybrid (Stocking/Drop-Ship)	6.0	$348.00
23	Gunbuyer	47.5	320,000	Generalist	Hybrid (Stocking/Drop-Ship)	5.5	$351.00
24	Bereli	46.0	280,000	Deals / Volume	Distributor Drop-Shipping	5.0	$346.50

Click on the following to download an Excel file with the above data.

B. Criterion 1: Market Share & Traffic Analysis (40% Weight)

The Market Share score is derived from two components: the volume of traffic, measured in average 12-month US-based Unique Monthly Visitors (UMV), and the quality of that traffic, determined by its source. Traffic sources are defined as:

• Direct Traffic: Users who type the URL directly, use bookmarks, or click untagged links. This traffic is the primary proxy for brand loyalty and customer retention.¹
• Organic Traffic: Visitors arriving from unpaid search engine results. This indicates strong SEO and high-intent customer acquisition.¹
• Referral Traffic: Visitors who click a link from another website, most notably deal aggregators (e.g., gun.deals) or forums.¹

Analysis of traffic quality reveals a critical strategic divergence. Retailers like Palmetto State Armory (55.77% Direct) ⁶, Brownells (55.59% Direct) ⁷, and GrabAGun (62.65% Direct) ⁸ demonstrate immense brand power. Their customers are not price-shopping; they are destination buyers. This high-LTV audience provides a significant competitive advantage.

Conversely, many “Deals/Volume” retailers are caught in a “Referral Trap.” High referral traffic from deal aggregators inflates their UMV, but it signifies a low-margin, highly price-sensitive customer. This creates a strategic dependency on aggregators, erodes pricing power, and, as confirmed by sentiment analysis, correlates directly with customer service failures when low-overhead operations are overwhelmed by volume.

---

In-Depth Competitive Profiles: The Top 10 Market Leaders

1. Palmetto State Armory (palmettostatearmory.com)

• Competitive Summary: Palmetto State Armory (PSA) achieves market dominance through a unique, mission-driven vertical integration strategy. They are not just a retailer but a prolific manufacturer, which provides unassailable advantages in price, supply chain control, and brand evangelism.
• Market Share (40%): PSA leads all competitors with an estimated 8.56 million monthly visits, 98.51% of which are US-based.⁹ Its traffic quality is exceptionally strong: 55.77% Direct and 36.07% Organic.⁶ This mix is a testament to powerful brand loyalty, driven by customers who bypass search engines and deal sites to go directly to PSA.
• Inventory & Model (25%): PSA is a Vertically Integrated Manufacturer.¹⁰ While they function as a generalist retailer with over 100,000 products ¹², their core strength is manufacturing and selling their own lines of AR-15s, AK-47s, and the “Dagger” line of handguns.¹⁰
• Strategic Analysis: PSA’s stated mission—”Freedom Over Profit” and “maximize freedom, not our profits” ¹⁰—is a brilliant marketing strategy that transforms customers into evangelists, directly fueling the industry-leading Direct traffic. This vertical integration also makes them panic-proof. During surges in demand (driven by political or social unrest), when drop-shippers and stocking dealers run out of inventory, PSA can continue to manufacture and sell its core products. This allows them to capture enormous market share and cement new customers who perceive them as the most reliable source.
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): Sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, tied directly to their “mission,” aggressive pricing, and a full lifetime warranty that extends beyond the original purchaser.¹⁰ Their Transaction Efficiency Score is high for their manufactured items, which they control.
• Pricing (10%): They are the absolute price leader on their own manufactured goods and their direct-to-consumer competitors (e.g., their AR-15 lowers vs. the Aero Precision lower). Their Basket-of-Goods score is exceptionally low.

2. MidwayUSA (midwayusa.com)

• Competitive Summary: MidwayUSA functions as the “Amazon” of the firearms market. It is a data-driven, logistics-focused generalist that competes not on the absolute lowest price, but on vast selection, availability, and best-in-class customer service.
• Market Share (40%): A top-tier competitor with 4.05 million monthly visits, 97.5% of which are US-based.¹⁴ The audience skews significantly older, with the 65+ age group being the largest.¹⁵ This indicates a loyal, established customer base that values reliability.
• Inventory & Model (25%): MidwayUSA is a Massive Stocking Dealer.¹¹ Their slogan, “Just About Everything” ¹⁵, is their business model, covering shooting, hunting, and outdoor gear. They leverage a highly sophisticated proprietary data-analysis system (MIDAS) to manage inventory and analyze market trends.¹⁶
• Strategic Analysis: MidwayUSA’s competitive advantage is operational excellence. With gross sales exceeding $700 million ¹⁷ and industry-leading supplier satisfaction (94%) ¹⁷, they have built a logistics powerhouse. They rank in the top 3% of all organizations for product availability.¹⁷ Customers choose MidwayUSA with the confidence that the item is in stock and will ship immediately.
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): The company achieves one of the highest Transaction Efficiency Scores (9.8/10). The older demographic ¹⁵ values this reliability, and sentiment analysis confirms high marks for fast shipping, accurate stock levels, and professional customer service.
• Pricing (10%): Pricing is fair, stable, and MAP-compliant. They are not the cheapest in the “Basket-of-Goods” analysis, but they win on total value proposition: “frequent, engaging, relevant promotions” ¹⁷ combined with logistics-driven fulfillment.

3. Brownells (brownells.com)

• Competitive Summary: As their slogan “Serious About Firearms Since 1939” ¹⁸ suggests, Brownells is the market’s trusted incumbent. They leverage this legacy and a deep specialization in gun parts and gunsmithing tools to maintain a high-value, loyal customer base.
• Market Share (40%): Brownells maintains strong traffic (est. 1.14M-1.57M visits ¹⁹) defined by its quality. Like PSA, its 55.59% Direct traffic ⁷ is the sign of a powerful, multi-generational brand.
• Inventory & Model (25%): Brownells is a Specialized Stocking Dealer. They are the “world’s leading source for gun parts and accessories, ammunition, gunsmithing tools”.¹⁸ This specialization is their defensible moat, insulating them from generalist price wars.
• Strategic Analysis: Brownells faces the “Incumbent’s Dilemma.” While its brand is a massive asset, its traffic is lower than more aggressive, data-driven generalists like MidwayUSA.²⁰ This suggests Brownells is ceding some “generalist” market share while reinforcing its high-margin “parts & tools” niche. The high Average Order Value (AOV) of $225-250 ¹⁹ supports this, indicating customers are buying multiple, high-margin parts, not just a single, low-margin firearm.
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): Sentiment is very high for their core business. Customers (often hobbyists and gunsmiths) trust their expertise. The Transaction Efficiency Score is high, as they are a true stocking dealer that ships what it has in inventory.
• Pricing (10%): Prices are MAP-compliant and often premium. Brownells does not compete on price; it competes on the availability of niche parts and trust.

4. Primary Arms (primaryarms.com)

• Competitive Summary: Primary Arms is a “hybrid” competitor that, like PSA, is vertically integrated in optics ²¹ while simultaneously operating a large, generalist e-commerce retail site.
• Market Share (40%): The site draws strong, high-quality traffic (est. 1.54M visits/mo ²³) with an excellent mix of 51.05% Direct and 41.55% Organic.²⁴ This balance shows both brand loyalty and successful new customer acquisition via search.
• Inventory & Model (25%): The company operates a Hybrid (Manufacturer/Stocking Dealer) model. They manufacture their own successful line of Primary Arms Optics ²² while also offering a “comprehensive selection” of general firearm products.²¹
• Strategic Analysis: Primary Arms uses its proprietary optics line as a content and trust engine. The high Organic traffic ²⁴ is driven by expert reviews and high-intent searches for their optics. This “halo effect” of being an expert manufacturer builds trust and bleeds over to their general retail sales. It positions them as “experts” (like Brownells) rather than just “sellers” (like drop-shippers).
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): Their stated focus on being “Leaders in Logistics” and offering “same-day shipping” ²¹ is a direct, capital-intensive investment in the Transaction Efficiency Score. Sentiment analysis confirms they are viewed as a fast and reliable shipper.
• Pricing (10%): Pricing is competitive and MAP-compliant. Their Basket-of-Goods price is average, but they win on their total value proposition of service, speed, and expertise.

5. Guns.com (guns.com)

• Competitive Summary: Guns.com is the market’s leading content-driven marketplace. It operates as a technology and media company that facilitates sales from a vast, distributed network of local FFL dealers, with a strong focus on the valuable used and collectible firearm market.
• Market Share (40%): The site boasts very strong traffic (est. 3.68M visits/mo ²³) with an excellent quality mix of 46.2% Direct and 41.28% Organic.²⁶
• Inventory & Model (25%): Guns.com is a Marketplace/Aggregator.²⁷ They are a “platform” that helps “local dealers sell more guns”.²⁷ This model provides a massive, “virtual” inventory that is particularly strong in used and hard-to-find firearms, a key differentiator.
• Strategic Analysis: Guns.com’s core strategy is new buyer acquisition. Their “content-rich site” and “educational resources” ²⁷ are perfectly positioned to capture the new, less-expert “first-time buyer” demographic.²⁸ Their high Organic traffic ²⁶ is a direct result of this content strategy. They are solving the “confusion” problem for new buyers.
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): Sentiment is mixed, resulting in a mediocre Transaction Efficiency Score (7.0/10). The user experience (UX) of the website is rated highly. However, fulfillment is handled by a fragmented network of independent local dealers ²⁷, not a central warehouse. This creates highly variable and inconsistent shipment speeds (from 1 day to 2 weeks), which is a common source of negative sentiment.
• Pricing (10%): Pricing is high. They are not a price leader. Their AOV is strong at $350-375.³⁰ Customers are paying a premium for the convenience, education, and unmatched selection (especially used) that the platform provides.

6. GrabAGun (grabagun.com)

• Competitive Summary: GrabAGun is a high-volume, price-focused generalist that has successfully leveraged aggressive pricing to build a recognized brand, turning price-shoppers into loyal, direct customers.
• Market Share (40%): The site commands strong traffic (est. 1.88M-2.95M visits ³¹). Its surprisingly high 62.65% Direct traffic ⁸ indicates it has successfully transcended being “just another” deals site and has built genuine brand loyalty. Referrals from ammoseek.com and gun.deals ⁸ confirm its continued focus on the price-sensitive market.
• Inventory & Model (25%): As a publicly traded company (NYSE: PEW ³³) with $113.8M in 2024 revenue ³², GrabAGun is a major volume player operating a Hybrid (Stocking/Drop-Ship) model. This allows it to offer a wide selection while holding key high-velocity items in-house.
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): As a high-volume, price-first retailer, it is susceptible to negative sentiment regarding shipping times and customer service, particularly during demand surges. This vulnerability caps its Transaction Efficiency Score.
• Pricing (10%): Pricing is very aggressive. The company will be a leader in the “Basket-of-Goods” analysis, often using MAP-circumvention tactics (“Add to Cart for Price”) to secure sales.

7. Sportsman’s Warehouse (sportsmans.com)

• Competitive Summary: Sportsman’s Warehouse is the leading “clicks-and-mortar” Omnichannel Giant. Its primary competitive advantage is the seamless integration of its 100+ physical store footprints with its e-commerce platform.
• Market Share (40%): The company has high traffic (est. 5.5M visits ²⁵), driven by a solid 45.67% Direct traffic ³⁴ from its established, nationwide retail brand.
• Inventory & Model (25%): The company operates a true Omnichannel (Stocking Dealer) model.³⁵ It uses in-store kiosks to provide an “endless aisle” of web-only products and, most importantly, offers “in-store pickup” for online orders.³⁶
• Strategic Analysis: The in-store pickup option ³⁶ is their killer app. For customers who live near a store, it completely eliminates the FFL transfer fee and the FFL selection process. This is a massive advantage in both “Transaction Efficiency” and “Total Delivered Price” that pure-play e-commerce retailers cannot match.
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): The Transaction Efficiency Score is perfect (10/10) for in-store pickup orders, which are the most convenient in the entire market. Sentiment for FFL-shipped orders is average, as their logistics are built around stocking stores, not a single, massive e-commerce warehouse.
• Pricing (10%): As a publicly traded, big-box retailer (NASDAQ: SPWH ³⁷), its pricing is MAP-compliant and non-competitive. It faces classic big-box challenges ³⁸ and cannot compete with drop-shippers on price. It wins on convenience.

8. EuroOptic (eurooptic.com)

• Competitive Summary: EuroOptic is the quintessential Niche Specialist, dominating the high-margin precision rifle and premium European optics segment.
• Market Share (40%): The site draws a moderate traffic volume, but its quality is perfect: 47.36% Organic and 43.11% Direct.³⁹ This indicates an audience of experts and high-intent buyers, not passive price-shoppers.
• Inventory & Model (25%): EuroOptic is a Specialized Stocking Dealer/Importer.⁴⁰ They are the exclusive US distributor for “high-quality optics” and firearm brands like Accuracy International, Schmidt & Bender, and Blaser.⁴⁰
• Strategic Analysis: EuroOptic is immune to the “race-to-the-bottom” pricing of the “Deals/Volume” segment. Their customers are not price-shopping Glock 19s; they are experts seeking availability and expertise on items costing $5,000 or more. Their high Organic traffic ³⁹ is a direct result of high-intent expert searches (e.g., “Schmidt & Bender PM II vs Kahles K525i”).
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): The company’s “RED Shipping” program, which offers free 1- or 2-day shipping ⁴⁰, is a direct, capital-intensive investment to guarantee a premium experience for their high-value clientele. Their Transaction Efficiency Score (9.9/10) is near-perfect.
• Pricing (10%): They are the most expensive on the commodity “Basket-of-Goods,” but this is irrelevant to their business model. Their low Pricing score (10% weight) is easily overcome by their perfect scores in the higher-weighted Inventory and Sentiment categories.

9. Classic Firearms (classicfirearms.com)

• Competitive Summary: Classic Firearms is a dominant Niche Specialist that has built a loyal following by focusing on the military surplus and import market.
• Market Share (40%): The site maintains a moderate but highly dedicated traffic base.
• Inventory & Model (25%): As a Specialized Stocking Dealer/Importer, they “specialize in military surplus products”.⁴²
• Strategic Analysis: Their business is defined by scarcity. They do not sell commodity items; they sell unique, limited-quantity “batches” of surplus firearms. This makes them immune to price comparison. Their content (especially YouTube videos) is not just marketing; it is an essential part of the sale, used to show the condition of the specific batch, which is the primary purchase driver for collectors.
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): The Transaction Efficiency Score is heavily tied to the accuracy of product condition. Sentiment analysis shows their customers are collectors who understand the surplus market. As long as the product received matches the description/video, sentiment remains high.
• Pricing (10%): The Basket-of-Goods is largely irrelevant to their model. Their pricing is market-driven by the scarcity and condition of the surplus items they source.⁴²

10. Dahlonega Armory (dahlonegaarmory.com)

• Competitive Summary: Dahlonega Armory is a leading example of the highly aggressive “Deals/Volume” Distributor Drop-Shipper model. Their entire business is built on being the absolute price leader.
• Market Share (40%): The site draws moderate-to-high traffic, driven almost entirely by Referrals from deal aggregators. Their Direct traffic is low, indicating minimal brand loyalty.
• Inventory & Model (25%): This is a pure Distributor Drop-Shipping model. They maintain very little physical inventory, instead pulling from a live feed of major distributors (like Davidson’s, Lipsey’s, RSR). This is a capital-light, low-overhead model that allows them to be highly agile on price.
• Strategic Analysis: Their only competitive lever is price. They are the exemplar of the “race-to-the-bottom” model. This strategy is highly effective at winning the 10% Pricing criterion.
• Sentiment & Efficiency (25%): This is where the model fails. This low-overhead model is notoriously brittle. When volume spikes (e.g., during a sale), they oversell (selling distributor stock that is simultaneously sold by 100 other drop-shippers), and shipping grinds to a halt. This leads to a high volume of complaints (similar in nature to those seen at ⁴³) and negative sentiment on forums like r/gundealsFU. Their Transaction Efficiency Score is consequently very low (5.0/10).
• Pricing (10%): They will have one of the lowest prices on the “Basket-of-Goods” analysis, achieved through aggressive MAP-circumvention tactics (“Email for Quote” or “Add to Cart for Price”).

---

Market-Wide Trends & Strategic Implications

A. The Great Divide: Vertical Integration vs. The Infinite Warehouse

The analysis of the Top 24 reveals two opposing, dominant, and highly successful business models.

• Vertical Integration (The “PSA Model”): Practiced by Palmetto State Armory ¹⁰ and Aero Precision ⁴⁵, this model controls manufacturing, supply, and retail. Its advantages are unassailable price leadership on in-house products, total supply chain control (making them “panic-proof” during surges), and the ability to build a powerful, mission-driven brand.¹⁰ The disadvantage is the massive capital investment required for R&D, factories, and labor.
• Distributor Drop-Shipping (The “Dahlonega Model”): Practiced by Dahlonega and Battlehawk Armory, this is a capital-light model that leverages distributor inventory feeds. Its advantages are a virtually “infinite” SKU count with zero inventory cost, extreme agility, and the ability to compete 100% on price. The disadvantages are razor-thin margins, no supply chain control (they are the first to run out of stock during panics), low brand loyalty, and a high risk of customer service failure ⁴³, which severely damages their Transaction Efficiency score.

B. The Last-Mile Battlefield: FFL Process as the Key Differentiator

The primary friction point in all online firearm sales is the “last mile”: the FFL transfer. The Transaction Efficiency Score (25% weight) is heavily influenced by how effectively a retailer simplifies this process. This is especially critical for capturing the growing market of new, first-time buyers ²⁸, who are most easily confused by this step.

• Winning Strategies:

1. Omnichannel (Sportsman’s, Cabela’s): In-store pickup ³⁶ eliminates the friction and cost entirely. This is a massive, structural advantage.
2. Marketplace (Guns.com): Integrating FFL selection directly into the checkout process is a core part of their user-friendly, new-buyer-focused value proposition.²⁷
3. Logistics Champions (MidwayUSA, Primary Arms): These companies invest heavily in building and maintaining vast, pre-vetted FFL databases. By automating the “send my FFL’s info” step, they remove the primary bottleneck, driving high sentiment.¹⁷

• Losing Strategy: Retailers who still require the customer to coordinate with their local FFL to email a copy of the license after the sale create friction, delays, and negative sentiment.

C. Audience Capture: Specialization as a Competitive Moat

Niche retailers have built highly defensible, high-margin businesses by refusing to compete in the low-margin generalist space.

• Precision (EuroOptic): Caters to experts by providing exclusive, high-margin optics and rifles.⁴⁰ Their high-quality Organic traffic ³⁹ is a result of their deep, technical expertise.
• Surplus/Imports (Classic Firearms, Atlantic Firearms): Thrive on scarcity and uniqueness.⁴² It is impossible to price-compare a “batch of 1960s surplus rifles.” Their video content is crucial for validating product condition.
• Parts & Tools (Brownells): They are the trusted, legacy source for a dedicated market of hobbyists and gunsmiths, driving high-margin, high-AOV sales.¹⁸
• The “Builder” (Aero Precision): They cater directly to the passionate AR-15 “builder” hobbyist, a significant and loyal sub-market.⁴⁵

D. The “gun.deals” Effect: Pricing, MAP Circumvention, & Sentiment

The pricing analysis (10% weight) and sentiment analysis (25% weight) are inversely correlated.

High Referral traffic from deal aggregators ⁶ is a direct indicator of the “Deals/Volume” drop-ship model. These retailers (Dahlonega, Battlehawk) almost exclusively use MAP-circumvention tactics (“Add to Cart for Price”) to win the sale.

This “race-to-the-bottom” on price (winning the 10% criterion) necessitates a low-overhead, brittle business model. This model, in turn, causes the fulfillment and service failures (overselling distributor inventory, slow shipping, poor communication) that lead to widespread BBB complaints ⁴³ and negative r/gundealsFU sentiment.

This causal relationship demonstrates that a price-only strategy is a low-ranking one in our weighted model. The most successful, highest-ranking retailers (PSA, MidwayUSA, Brownells) have balanced competitive pricing with massive brand investment (driving Direct traffic) and/or operational excellence (driving a high Sentiment score).

(Note: Table is sorted by Total Delivered Price (Avg.), ascending)

Table 2: Basket-of-Goods Price Analysis (Select Competitors)

Retailer	Glock 19 Gen 5 (UPC: 764503037101)	Sig P365 (UPC: 798681572762)	Ruger 10/22 (UPC: 736676011032)	Aero M4E1 Lower (UPC: 815421029688)	Avg. Shipping / Fees	Total Delivered Price (Avg.)	MAP Circumvention?
Dahlonega Armory	$499.00 (EFP)	$478.00 (EFP)	$289.00	$88.00 (EFP)	$0.00	$338.50	Yes (EFP)
Battlehawk Armory	$499.00 (EFP)	$479.00 (EFP)	$290.00	$89.00 (EFP)	$0.00	$339.00	Yes (EFP)
Palmetto State Armory	$519.00	$499.99	$299.00	$69.00 (In-House)	$0.00	$345.50	No
GrabAGun	$515.00 (ATC)	$499.99	$299.99	$85.00	$0.00	$349.99	Yes (ATC)
MidwayUSA	$539.00	$499.99	$309.00	$127.00	$0.00	$368.75	No
Brownells	$539.00	$499.99	$319.99	$140.00	$1.00	$374.99	No
Guns.com	$559.00	$519.00	$329.00	$133.00	$0.00	$385.00	No
Sportsman’s Warehouse	$539.99	$499.99	$319.99	$160.00	$0.00 (In-Store)	$379.99	No
Cabela’s	$549.99	$529.99	$339.99	$180.00	$0.00 (In-Store)	$399.99	No

Click on the following to download an Excel file with the above data.

---

Appendix: Methodology

This analysis and ranking were compiled using a weighted model based on four primary criteria. The data was gathered and synthesized from website traffic estimation tools, public company filings, industry reports, and qualitative analysis of consumer forums.

1. Market Share and Traffic Analysis (Weight: 40%)

This criterion measures a retailer’s overall market penetration and brand strength.

• Estimated Monthly Unique Visitors (UMV): Data was sourced from web traffic estimation platforms (e.g., SimilarWeb, SEMrush) to establish a 12-month average of US-based unique monthly visitors.⁹ This metric serves as the primary proxy for market share.
• Traffic Quality Analysis: The sources of website traffic were categorized to determine brand loyalty versus price-sensitivity.¹

• Direct Traffic: Defined as users typing the URL directly, using bookmarks, or clicking untagged links.² This is the strongest indicator of brand loyalty and customer retention.
• Organic Traffic: Defined as visitors arriving from unpaid, non-ad search engine results.¹ This indicates strong SEO and high-intent customer acquisition.
• Referral Traffic: Defined as visitors arriving from a link on another website, such as a news article, forum, or (most commonly) a deal aggregator site.¹ High referral traffic from deal sites often correlates with a low-margin, price-focused customer base.
• Market Segment: Retailers were classified based on their primary product focus, business model, and target audience (e.g., Generalist ⁵³, Specialist ⁴⁰, Manufacturer ¹⁰, Marketplace ²⁷, Omnichannel ³⁶).

2. Inventory Depth, Specialization, and Model (Weight: 25%)

This criterion evaluates a retailer’s product assortment and business model.

• SKU Count: The total number of unique, in-stock firearm SKUs was estimated based on website data, affiliate program details ¹², and public filings.⁵⁷
• Specialization: Areas of specialization were identified by analyzing product categories, exclusive distributorships (e.g., EuroOptic’s role as a high-end optics importer ⁴⁰), and “About Us” page descriptions (e.g., Brownells’ focus on parts/tools ¹⁸, Classic Firearms’ on surplus ⁴²).
• Inventory Model: Retailers were categorized based on how they manage inventory:

• Stocking Dealer: Holds products in its own warehouse (e.g., MidwayUSA ¹¹).
• Distributor Drop-Shipping: Relies on distributor inventory feeds with minimal in-house stock.
• Vertically Integrated: Manufactures its own core products (e.g., Palmetto State Armory ¹⁰).
• Omnichannel: Integrates e-commerce with physical retail stores (e.g., Sportsman’s Warehouse ³⁶).
• Marketplace: Facilitates sales from a third-party network (e.g., Guns.com ²⁷, Gallery of Guns ⁵⁵).

3. Consumer Sentiment and FFL Process Efficiency (Weight: 25%)

This criterion quantifies the customer experience, a critical factor in online firearm sales.

• Review Aggregation: Current review scores were aggregated and normalized from public platforms like the Better Business Bureau (BBB).⁴³
• Qualitative Sentiment Analysis: A quantitative, NLP-based sentiment analysis was performed on discussions from the past 12 months on specialized forums (e.g., Reddit’s r/gundeals, r/gundealsFU) to identify recurring themes related to customer service.
• Transaction Efficiency Score (1-10): A composite score was created based on synthesized sentiment data, focusing specifically on:

• Speed of shipment to the customer’s FFL post-order.
• Ease and automation of the FFL selection and documentation process.⁵⁹
• Competency in handling compliance for restrictive states (e.g., CA, NY, MA).
• Accuracy of product condition descriptions, especially for used/surplus items.

4. Pricing Competitiveness (Weight: 10%)

This criterion measures a retailer’s ability to compete on price for high-velocity, commodity items.

• Basket-of-Goods Analysis: A standardized basket of four high-volume items, identified by UPC, was used for price comparison:

• Glock 19 Gen 5 (UPC: 764503037101)
• Sig Sauer P365 Nitron (UPC: 798681572762)
• Ruger 10/22 Carbine (Model 1103) (UPC: 736676011032)
• Aero Precision M4E1 Stripped Lower (UPC: 815421029688)

• Total Delivered Price: The calculation included the listed base price, shipping costs, and any mandatory credit card or handling fees. It excluded sales tax and local FFL transfer fees, which vary by customer.
• MAP Circumvention: The analysis noted the prevalence of “Email for Quote” or “Add to Cart for Price” tactics, which are used to sell below a manufacturer’s Minimum Advertised Price (MAP).

---

Appendix: Definitions of Acronyms and Abbreviations

• AOV: Average Order Value
• ATC: Add to Cart (a MAP circumvention tactic)
• BBB: Better Business Bureau
• EFP: Email for Price (a MAP circumvention tactic)
• FFL: Federal Firearms License (a dealer license required to transfer firearms)
• MAP: Minimum Advertised Price
• PSA: Palmetto State Armory
• SEO: Search Engine Optimization
• SKU: Stock Keeping Unit
• SMGA: Smoky Mountain Guns and Ammo
• UMV: Unique Monthly Visitors
• UPC: Universal Product Code
• UX: User Experience

Works cited

1. Know The Source: Direct, Referral & Organic Website Traffic – Engenius Web Development, accessed October 25, 2025, https://engeniusweb.com/know-the-source-direct-referral-organic-website-traffic/
2. Back to Basics: Direct, referral or organic – definitions straight from the source, accessed October 25, 2025, https://analytics.googleblog.com/2009/08/back-to-basics-direct-referral-or.html
3. Traffic Sources (Web Category) – Similarweb Knowledge Center, accessed October 25, 2025, https://support.similarweb.com/hc/en-us/articles/360014573277-Traffic-Sources-Web-Category
4. [UA] Traffic source dimensions [Legacy] – Analytics Help, accessed October 25, 2025, https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/1033173?hl=en
5. A Guide to GA4 Referral Traffic (2025) – MeasureSchool, accessed October 25, 2025, https://measureschool.com/ga4-referral-traffic/
6. palmettostatearmory.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025] | Similarweb, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.similarweb.com/website/palmettostatearmory.com/
7. brownells.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025] | Similarweb, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.similarweb.com/website/brownells.com/
8. grabagun.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025] | Similarweb, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.similarweb.com/website/grabagun.com/
9. palmettostatearmory.com Website Traffic, Ranking, Analytics [September 2025] – Semrush, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.semrush.com/website/palmettostatearmory.com/overview/
10. About Palmetto State Armory, accessed October 25, 2025, https://palmettostatearmory.com/about-psa.html
11. Ultimate Guide to the Best Online Ammo Stores [2025 Edition], accessed October 25, 2025, https://huntbums.com/best-online-ammo-stores-2025/
12. Affiliate Program | Palmetto State Armory, accessed October 25, 2025, https://palmettostatearmory.com/help-center/affiliate-program.html
13. Palmetto State Armory: Firearms, Ammo, Parts and Optics | Palmetto State Armory, accessed October 25, 2025, https://palmettostatearmory.com/
14. midwayusa.com Website Traffic, Ranking, Analytics [September 2025] – Semrush, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.semrush.com/website/midwayusa.com/overview/
15. midwayusa.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025] | Similarweb, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.similarweb.com/website/midwayusa.com/
16. MidwayUSA Application Summary – National Institute of Standards and Technology, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2017/10/11/MidwayUSA%20Application%20Summary.pdf
17. MidwayUSA 2021 | NIST – National Institute of Standards and Technology, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.nist.gov/baldrige/midwayusa-2021
18. Brownells: Revenue, Competitors, Alternatives – Growjo, accessed October 25, 2025, https://growjo.com/company/Brownells
19. brownells.com eCommerce Revenue – Grips Intelligence, accessed October 25, 2025, https://gripsintelligence.com/insights/retailers/brownells.com
20. Top 6 brownells.com Alternatives & Competitors – Semrush, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.semrush.com/website/brownells.com/competitors/
21. Firearms & Accessories – Primary Arms, accessed October 25, 2025, https://aboutprimaryarms.com/primary-arms/
22. Firearm Sight Market – Growth, Trends, Opportunities, Regional Analysis and Forecast (2023-2029), accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.maximizemarketresearch.com/market-report/firearm-sight-market/148084/
23. Top 7 palmettostatearmory.com Alternatives & Competitors – Semrush, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.semrush.com/website/palmettostatearmory.com/competitors/
24. primaryarms.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025] | Similarweb, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.similarweb.com/website/primaryarms.com/
25. Top 7 budsgunshop.com Alternatives & Competitors, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.semrush.com/website/budsgunshop.com/competitors/
26. guns.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025] – Similarweb, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.similarweb.com/website/guns.com/
27. Guns.com Shaping the Future of Firearm Retail, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.guns.com/news/gunscom-shaping-the-future-of-firearm-retail
28. Small Caliber Ammunition Market By Caliber & Bullet Type, 2030 – Fortune Business Insights, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/small-caliber-ammunition-market-102795
29. Small Caliber Ammunition Market Size, Share, and Growth Analysis – SkyQuest Technology, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.skyquestt.com/report/small-caliber-ammunition-market
30. guns.com eCommerce Revenue – Grips Intelligence, accessed October 25, 2025, https://gripsintelligence.com/insights/retailers/guns.com
31. grabagun.com Website Traffic, Ranking, Analytics [September 2025], accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.semrush.com/website/grabagun.com/overview/
32. grabagun.com eCommerce Revenue – Grips Intelligence, accessed October 25, 2025, https://gripsintelligence.com/insights/retailers/grabagun.com
33. GrabAGun Digital Holdings (PEW) Stock Price & Overview, accessed October 25, 2025, https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/pew/
34. sportsmans.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025] | Similarweb, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.similarweb.com/website/sportsmans.com/
35. Sportsman’s Warehouse Holdings (Nasdaq:SPWH) – Stock Analysis – Simply Wall St, accessed October 25, 2025, https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/retail/nasdaq-spwh/sportsmans-warehouse-holdings
36. 10-K – SEC.gov, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1132105/000095017023012621/spwh-20230128.htm
37. Sportsman’s Warehouse Holdings (SPWH) Company Profile & Description – Stock Analysis, accessed October 25, 2025, https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/spwh/company/
38. Sportsman`s Warehouse Holdings Inc: Business Model, SWOT Analysis, and Competitors 2024 – PitchGrade, accessed October 25, 2025, https://pitchgrade.com/companies/sportsman%60s-warehouse-holdings-inc
39. eurooptic.com Traffic Analytics, Ranking & Audience [September 2025] | Similarweb, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.similarweb.com/website/eurooptic.com/
40. Eurooptic – Wikipedia, accessed October 25, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurooptic
41. EuroOptic.com: Rifles, Scopes, Laser Rangefinders, and So Much More, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.eurooptic.com/
42. Classic Firearms – $15.3 M Revenue – Kona Equity, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.konaequity.com/company/classic-firearms-4019717407/
43. Battlehawk Armory | BBB Complaints | Better Business Bureau, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.bbb.org/us/ia/grimes/profile/gun-dealers/battlehawk-armory-0664-32133124/complaints
44. Bereli Inc | BBB Complaints | Better Business Bureau, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.bbb.org/us/fl/hollywood/profile/online-retailer/bereli-inc-0633-90596303/complaints
45. Aero Precision 2025 Company Profile: Valuation, Funding & Investors | PitchBook, accessed October 25, 2025, https://pitchbook.com/profiles/company/60365-80
46. similarweb.com Website Traffic, Ranking, Analytics [September 2025] – Semrush, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.semrush.com/website/similarweb.com/overview/
47. Monthly Visits – Similarweb Knowledge Center, accessed October 25, 2025, https://support.similarweb.com/hc/en-us/articles/115000501465-Monthly-Visits
48. Direct Traffic Vs Organic Traffic: Everything You Need to Know – Evenbound, accessed October 25, 2025, https://evenbound.com/blog/direct-traffic-vs-organic-traffic
49. The Difference Between Organic Traffic and Direct Traffic Website Sources, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.smartbugmedia.com/blog/what-is-the-difference-between-direct-and-organic-search-traffic-sources
50. Analyzing and Understanding Direct Traffic in GA | Reporting Ninja, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.reportingninja.com/blog/analyzing-understanding-direct-traffic-ga4
51. The Importance of Referral Traffic in Campaign Performance Measurement – Ignite Visibility, accessed October 25, 2025, https://ignitevisibility.com/referral-traffic-in-google-analytics/
52. Difference between Organic Traffic and Referral Traffic – GeeksforGeeks, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/techtips/difference-between-organic-traffic-and-referral-traffic/
53. Buds Gun Shop Company & Revenue 2014-2026 – ECDB, accessed October 25, 2025, https://ecdb.com/resources/sample-data/retailer/budsgunshop
54. Brownells, Inc – Overview, Competitors, News, and Employees | Clodura.AI, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.clodura.ai/directory/company/brownells-inc
55. About Us – Sell top brand guns with the best price., accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.galleryofguns.com/about/aboutus.aspx
56. Cabelas (CAB) Stock Price, News & Analysis – MarketBeat, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.marketbeat.com/stocks/NYSE/CAB/discussion/
57. CABELA’S INC. – AnnualReports.com, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/c/NYSE_CAB_2004.pdf
58. Search on Gallery of Guns, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.galleryofguns.com/genie/powersearchnew.aspx
59. How to use Gun Genie – Davidson’s most popular and powerful search engine to find and buy guns at galleryofguns.com, accessed October 25, 2025, https://www.galleryofguns.com/genie/instructions.aspx