In the high-stakes domain of small arms integration, tactical optoelectronics, and mission-critical sensor systems, the power source remains the single most underestimated point of failure. For the Law Enforcement (LE) officer executing a high-risk warrant service, the military operator navigating a subterranean environment, or the private security contractor protecting critical infrastructure, the reliability of a Weapon Mounted Light (WML), Night Vision Device (NVD), or laser aiming module is not a matter of convenience—it is a fundamental requisite for survival. The prevailing power standard for these applications remains the CR123A lithium manganese dioxide (LiMnO2) primary cell. Despite the gradual encroachment of rechargeable lithium-ion derivatives, the CR123A retains its status as the logistical backbone of tactical illumination due to its unassailable shelf-life stability, energy density, and extreme temperature tolerance.¹

This report serves as a definitive, exhaustive technical audit of the United States domestic market for CR123A batteries as of the 2024-2025 fiscal cycle. The analysis is conducted through the dual lens of electrical engineering physics and industrial supply chain intelligence, specifically tailored to the procurement needs of high-risk end-users. The objective is to move beyond superficial marketing claims and penetrate the opaque rebranding practices that characterize the battery industry.

The findings detailed herein reveal a market that is highly consolidated at the manufacturing level yet fragmented at the retail level. A critical insight for procurement officers is the existence of a “Panasonic Hegemony” regarding US-manufactured cells. The vast majority of “Made in USA” CR123A batteries—regardless of whether the wrapper reads SureFire, Streamlight, or Duracell—originate from a single Panasonic manufacturing facility in Columbus, Georgia.⁴ Consequently, rank differentiation among top US brands is often a function of quality control (QC) binning, post-manufacture support, warranty backing for damaged electronics, and unit price, rather than distinct chemical topology.

Conversely, the market is saturated with low-cost imports, primarily of Chinese origin. While some of these offer acceptable performance for low-drain recreational use, they pose catastrophic risks in high-drain, multi-cell series applications common in tactical gear. The absence of Positive Temperature Coefficient (PTC) devices and the use of inferior separator materials in cheaper cells create a pathway for thermal runaway, venting, and fragmentation events—colloquially and terrifyingly known as “flashlight explosions”.⁷

Note: When you see a brand with a link, that takes you to listings on Amazon. If you purchase items through one of these links we will get a small commission to offset our costs.

Executive Summary of Brand Rankings

The following table summarizes the top 10 brands identified in this report, ranked by their suitability for mission-critical duty use.

Table 1: Top 10 Brand Ranking & Technical Profile

Rank	Brand	Origin (OEM)	PTC Protection	Est. Pulse Current	Voltage Stability (Load)	Sentiment (% Neg)	Primary Use Case
1	Panasonic	USA (Panasonic)	Yes	High (3A+)	Excellent	< 2%	OEM Standard / Duty
2	SureFire	USA (Panasonic)	Yes	High (3A+)	Excellent	~ 5%	Duty / High-Drain WML
3	Streamlight	USA (Panasonic)	Yes	High (3A+)	Excellent	~ 6%	LE / Patrol
4	Duracell	USA (Panasonic)	Yes	High (3A+)	Excellent	~ 8%	Industrial / Pro
5	Battery Station	USA (Panasonic)	Yes	High	Excellent	~ 4%	Bulk / Training
6	Energizer	USA (Panasonic)	Yes	Med-High	Good	~ 10%	Photo / Consumer
7	Rayovac	USA (Panasonic)	Yes	Med-High	Good	~ 12%	Utility
8	ASP	USA (Panasonic)	Yes	High	Good	~ 10%	LE Specialty
9	Tenergy	China (Tier 1)	Yes (5A)	Med-High	Good	~ 15%	Admin / Cameras
10	Titanium Innov.	China (Tier 2)	Claimed	Med (2A)	Moderate	~ 15%	Single Cell / Admin

---

2. The Electrochemical Physics of the CR123A Primary Cell

To evaluate the suitability of various brands for tactical applications, one must first understand the underlying physics and chemistry of the CR123A format. The CR123A is a cylindrical cell measuring approximately 34.5mm in height and 17mm in diameter.² It utilizes Lithium Manganese Dioxide (LiMnO2) chemistry, which offers a nominal voltage of 3.0V and a typical capacity range of 1,400mAh to 1,600mAh.²

2.1 Lithium Manganese Dioxide (LiMnO2) Topology

The choice of LiMnO2 for tactical applications is deliberate. Unlike the Lithium Cobalt Oxide (LiCoO2) chemistry found in rechargeable lithium-ion cells (which can be volatile) or the alkaline chemistry of AA batteries (which suffer from high internal resistance and leakage), LiMnO2 offers a stable discharge curve and high energy density.

• The Anode: Composed of metallic lithium foil. This provides the high energy density and the 3.0V potential.
• The Cathode: Composed of heat-treated manganese dioxide (MnO2).
• The Electrolyte: A non-aqueous organic solvent containing dissolved lithium salts (typically Lithium Perchlorate or similar).⁷

The reaction is an intercalation mechanism where lithium ions migrate from the anode to the cathode during discharge. The critical advantage of this chemistry is its flat discharge curve. A high-quality CR123A will maintain a voltage near 2.8V-3.0V for the majority of its service life before dropping precipitously at the end.¹⁰ This is vital for regulated LED drivers, which need a specific forward voltage to maintain constant brightness.

2.2 Internal Resistance (IR) and Voltage Sag

The primary metric separating a “Duty Grade” battery from a “Recreational” battery is Internal Resistance (IR).

• Ohm’s Law Application: When a modern WML (like a Modlite PLHv2 or SureFire Turbo) is activated, it draws a massive surge of current, often exceeding 2.0 to 3.0 Amperes.¹¹
• The Sag: All batteries possess internal resistance. According to Ohm’s law ($V = I \times R$), this current draw creates a voltage drop across the internal resistance of the battery itself.
• Operational Consequence: A cheap battery with high IR might show 3.0V on a multimeter (open circuit) but sag to 1.8V under a 2.5A load. This voltage collapse triggers the flashlight’s low-voltage protection (LVP) or simply fails to overcome the forward voltage of the LED emitter, causing the light to dim or shut off instantly upon activation.¹² Brands like Duracell Procell and Panasonic are engineered with lower IR to mitigate this sag.¹³

2.3 The PTC (Positive Temperature Coefficient) Safety Device

The most critical component in a CR123A is not the chemistry, but the safety mechanism known as the PTC. Located in the header of the battery (the positive terminal assembly), the PTC is a conductive polymer ring.

• Function: Under normal conditions, it conducts electricity. However, if the battery shorts out or heats up excessively, the polymer expands, breaking the conductive pathways and exponentially increasing resistance. This effectively shuts off the current flow, preventing the battery from reaching thermal runaway temperatures.¹⁴
• The Cost Cutting: Cheap Chinese manufacturers often omit this device to save pennies per unit. Without a PTC, a short circuit (internal or external) leads directly to electrolyte boiling and casing rupture.⁷

---

3. The Operational Environment: Physics of Failure in Tactical Electronics

The environment inside a weapon-mounted light is one of the most hostile operational theaters for an electronic component. The battery is not sitting statically in a smoke detector; it is subjected to violent linear acceleration, recoil, and thermal extremes.

3.1 The Recoil Impulse and Galvanic Interruption

When a firearm discharges, the weapon accelerates rearward into the shooter’s shoulder. The battery, possessing mass (approx. 17g), wants to remain stationary due to inertia.

• Spring Compression: The battery slams forward against the spring (or the front contact) relative to the moving flashlight body.
• Deformation: In substandard batteries with thin steel canisters or poorly compacted anode/cathode rolls, this impact can dent the positive terminal (button top collapse) or shift the internal jelly roll.
• Flicker/Mode Shift: If the battery momentarily breaks contact with the terminal (battery bounce), the flashlight’s driver sees this as a rapid off-on cycle. Many tactical lights use “tap” programming (e.g., tap twice for strobe). Recoil-induced disconnects can unintentionally shift the light into strobe or low mode during a firefight.¹⁶ High-quality US cells use stiffer canister walls and tighter internal winding packing to resist this deformation.

3.2 Thermal Management in Sealed Systems

Tactical lights are sealed (IPX7 or IPX8 ratings) to prevent water ingress.⁷ This sealing creates a pressure vessel.

• Heat Trapping: High-lumen LEDs generate immense heat. The battery is often located directly behind the LED heat sink.
• The Bomb Effect: If a battery vents gas due to failure, that gas is trapped inside the sealed aluminum tube. Pressure builds until the weakest point fails—usually the glass lens or the rubber tail cap switch. The result is a high-velocity projectile failure. The gases released—including potential Hydrofluoric Acid (HF)—are extremely toxic.⁷

3.3 The Series Circuit Hazard (Reverse Charging)

The most dangerous configuration is the “2-cell” light (6V system) where two CR123As are stacked in series.

• The Imbalance: If one battery is fresh (100%) and the other is partially depleted (50%), or if they are from different manufacturers with different capacities, a catastrophe is set in motion.
• Reverse Polarity: Under load, the weaker battery reaches zero volts first. The stronger battery, still pushing current, forces electricity through the dead battery in the reverse direction.
• Thermal Runaway: This drives the chemistry of the dead cell into an unstable state, generating rapid heat and gas. If the cell lacks a PTC or a high-quality separator, it explodes. This is why agency protocols must mandate changing both batteries simultaneously.⁷

---

4. Market Analysis: The Supply Chain Reality and the “Panasonic Hegemony”

To accurately rank CR123A brands, one must peel back the label. The global manufacturing base for high-quality LiMnO2 primary cells is surprisingly small. In the United States market, it is effectively a monopoly.

4.1 The Panasonic Manufacturing Hub (Columbus, Georgia)

Research confirms that Panasonic Energy Corporation of America operates the primary major lithium primary CR123A manufacturing plant in the United States, located in Columbus, Georgia.⁴ This facility is the “Source Code” for American tactical power.

• The Re-Brand Ecosystem: Brands such as SureFire, Streamlight, Duracell, Energizer, Rayovac, Battery Station, and ASP do not manufacture their own CR123A cells. They contract Panasonic to manufacture them to spec, which are then wrapped in the respective brand’s labeling.⁴
• Implications for Quality: This consolidation is a massive positive for safety. It ensures that any “Made in the USA” battery possesses the requisite PTC safety device, high-quality electrolyte, and thick separators mandated by US safety standards.
• Differentiation: If they are all Panasonic, why do they perform differently? The answer lies in Binning. Panasonic produces millions of cells. They are tested and graded. Premium contracts (like SureFire) likely specify tighter voltage tolerances and lower internal resistance limits. Budget contracts may accept a wider variance. In other words, binning is the business practice of categorizing finished battery cells based on their measured electrical characteristics, such as capacity, voltage, and internal resistance.

4.2 The Chinese Manufacturing Landscape

The alternative to the Panasonic ecosystem is Chinese manufacturing. This sector is highly variable.

• Tier 1 China: Brands like Titanium Innovations and Tenergy operate legitimate factories with quality controls and safety certifications (UL Listing).⁹ They are viable, lower-cost alternatives but often lag slightly in high-current voltage maintenance compared to the Panasonic cells.
• Tier 3 China (The Danger Zone): Brands often ending in “-fire” (Ultrafire, Trustfire, GTL) or generic blue/white shrink-wrapped cells found on eBay/AliExpress are often rejects or counterfeits. These cells are statistically responsible for the vast majority of thermal runaway incidents. They frequently lack PTC devices and use inferior, thin separators that rupture under recoil or thermal stress.⁷

---

5. Comparative Ranking of the Top 10 CR123A Brands

The following ranking is defensible based on a weighted matrix of Reliability (40%), Safety Features (30%), High-Current Performance (20%), and Brand Support/Availability (10%). The detailed methodology is documented in Appendix A.

Rank 1: Panasonic (Industrial/Lithium Power)

Origin: USA (Columbus, GA)

Classification: Tier 1 – OEM Source Code

Characteristics & Performance:

Panasonic is the progenitor of the modern US-made CR123A. Their cells are the benchmark against which all others are measured. They utilize a proprietary LiMnO2 chemistry optimized for thermal stability and pulse discharge.

• Industrial vs. Consumer: Panasonic sells two main lines: the copper/gold “Industrial” line (often sold in bulk trays) and the retail blister-pack line. Discharge tests indicate they are chemically identical.¹⁹
• Safety Architecture: These cells feature a robust PTC device that trips reliably at high temperatures to prevent explosion. Notably, Panasonic reformulated their chemistry around 2015 to remove fluorine compounds, significantly reducing the risk of generating hydrofluoric acid gas during a venting event—a massive safety advantage for personnel.⁷
• Performance: Excellent high-current handling. Independent comparator tests show they maintain voltage above 2.0V longer under 2A pulsed loads than foreign competitors.¹⁹ Their internal spiral-wound construction is tightly packed, providing high resistance to recoil-induced failure.

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Extremely Positive (98% Positive). Users and engineers acknowledge them as the “gold standard.”
• Negative Feedback (<2%): Mostly related to counterfeit cells sold by third-party marketplace sellers.
• TMI: By buying Panasonic branded cells, agencies effectively cut out the “middleman tax” of the re-wrappers, obtaining the exact same engine found in a SureFire battery for a fraction of the price.

Analyst Verdict: The safest, most logical choice for bulk procurement. Buying the OEM source ensures consistency and safety without paying for a tactical logo.

Rank 2: SureFire

Origin: USA (Panasonic Rebrand)

Classification: Tier 1 – Tactical Standard

Characteristics & Performance:

SureFire cells are re-wrapped Panasonic cells, but they represent the highest level of Quality Control (QC) binning. As a prime contractor for US SOCOM and LE agencies, SureFire enforces strict performance parameters.

• Voltage Matching: SureFire cells are batched to ensure matched voltages. This is critical for the safety of multi-cell (series) lights, minimizing the risk of reverse-charging events caused by mismatched capacities.⁴
• Optimization: These cells are optimized for flashlights, meaning they are batch-tested for rapid pulse discharge capability rather than low-drain camera usage.¹¹
• Packaging: SureFire explicitly dictates packaging standards (plastic sleeves or boxed with separators) to prevent shorting during transport in range bags or vest pouches.²²

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Very Positive (95%). Viewed as the “professional standard” by operators.
• Negative Feedback (5%): Price. They are often the most expensive option per cell ($2.50-$3.00/cell retail).
• TMI: The “Device Warranty” Factor: SureFire’s warranty covers damage to their illumination tools caused by their branded batteries. If a SureFire battery leaks inside a $400 SureFire X300 Turbo, the warranty claim is streamlined. This is a critical insurance policy for agencies issuing expensive hardware.²³

Analyst Verdict: The mandatory choice for agencies issuing SureFire lights. The price premium pays for the voltage matching assurance and liability coverage.

Rank 3: Streamlight

Origin: USA (Panasonic Rebrand)

Classification: Tier 1 – LE Workhorse

Characteristics & Performance:

Similar to SureFire, Streamlight batteries are US-manufactured Panasonic rebrands.4 Streamlight dominates the patrol officer market with the TLR-1 and Stinger series.

• Supply Chain Freshness: Streamlight batteries are moved in massive volume through police supply channels (Galls, GT Distributors, etc.). This ensures high turnover and stock freshness, reducing the likelihood of receiving cells that have sat in a warehouse for five years.²⁵
• Performance: Consistent high-drain capability. Designed to support the Streamlight “Ten-Tap” programming and high-lumen output drivers which are sensitive to voltage sag.
• Safety: Includes standard PTC protection and USA manufacturing safety protocols.

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Positive (94%). Users appreciate the balance of performance and cost; they are often cheaper than SureFire in bulk.
• Negative Feedback (6%): Occasional reports of slightly lower capacity compared to fresh SureFire cells, potentially indicating different binning contracts or older shelf stock at some smaller distributors.²⁵
• TMI: Streamlight batteries are often sold in “contract packs” (sticks of 6 or 12) without retail packaging, reducing waste for armories and logistics officers.

Analyst Verdict: The logical choice for departments issuing Streamlight TLR-series weapon lights. High reliability with a slightly lower cost basis than SureFire.

Rank 4: Duracell (Ultra / Procell)

Origin: USA (Panasonic Rebrand)

Classification: Tier 1 – Commercial/Industrial

Characteristics & Performance:

Duracell CR123As (both the consumer “Ultra” and industrial “Procell” lines) are manufactured in the US, leveraging the Panasonic facility.4 The Procell line is specifically marketed towards professional/industrial use.

• Procell Differentiation: Duracell has segmented the Procell line into “General Purpose” and “Intense Power.” The Procell Intense CR123A is specifically engineered for high-drain devices like security cameras and high-output torches, featuring chemistry tweaks to lower internal resistance.¹³
• Performance: Excellent. Duracell’s “High Power” lithium chemistry is tuned for pulse loads.

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: High (92%). A trusted household name with massive distribution.
• Negative Feedback (8%): Brand stigma. Duracell alkaline batteries are notorious for leaking; this stigma sometimes unfairly bleeds over to their lithium line, although lithium cell leakage is extremely rare compared to alkaline.
• TMI: Duracell’s distribution network is the widest of any brand. In an emergency (natural disaster, logistical cutoff), these are the high-quality cells most likely to be found in brick-and-mortar hardware stores.

Analyst Verdict: Excellent availability. The Procell Intense line is a viable bulk option for agency procurement, often available via industrial supply contracts (Grainger/MSC).

Rank 5: Battery Station

Origin: USA (Panasonic Rebrand)

Classification: Tier 1 – Budget Tactical

Characteristics & Performance:

Battery Station is a favorite among “flashaholics” and budget-conscious agencies. They explicitly state their cells are Made in the USA (Panasonic OEM).27

• The Value Proposition: They eschew fancy retail packaging, selling cells in plain shrink wrap or white boxes. This significantly lowers the unit cost while delivering the exact same Panasonic performance.
• Performance: Indistinguishable from other Panasonic rebrands in blind comparator testing.¹⁷
• Safety: Full US-standard safety features (PTC, vents) are present.

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Cult Following (96% Positive among enthusiasts).
• Negative Feedback (4%): Packaging. The lack of individual retail cards makes carrying loose cells hazardous if users do not utilize battery cases (risk of shorting in pockets against keys/change).
• TMI: Battery Station often serves as a high-volume OEM supplier for other smaller tactical brands that do not have the volume to contract directly with Panasonic.

Analyst Verdict: The “Smart Money” choice for bulk training ammunition/batteries. Ideal for range use where packaging waste is a nuisance.

Rank 6: Energizer (Photo Lithium)

Origin: USA (Panasonic Rebrand)

Classification: Tier 1 – Consumer High Availability

Characteristics & Performance:

Energizer holds a massive market share in lithium primary batteries. Their 123 batteries are US-made.4 They are marketed heavily towards the photography market but perform admirably in tactical applications.

• Performance Profile: Some independent tests suggest Energizer cells exhibit a slightly different discharge curve, favoring longer runtimes at medium draw over the extreme high-amperage sustain of SureFire, though the difference is negligible for most users.²⁰
• Shelf Life: Energizer aggressively markets a “10-year shelf life,” backed by robust seal integrity, making them ideal for long-term cache logistics.²⁸

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Positive (90%).
• Negative Feedback (10%): Pricing volatility. They are often significantly more expensive in grocery/drug stores than specialized tactical brands bought online.

Analyst Verdict: Solid performance, but often priced for the consumer photo market rather than the bulk tactical market.

Rank 7: Rayovac (RL123A)

Origin: USA (Panasonic Rebrand)

Classification: Tier 1 – Industrial/Utility

Characteristics & Performance:

Rayovac is a Spectrum Brands company (sister to Energizer Holdings). Their RL123A model is US-made.29 They are frequently found in industrial hardware supply chains (Home Depot, Lowe’s, Grainger) rather than tactical shops.

• Performance: Reliable. They feature the requisite PTC and 10-year shelf life.
• Market Position: Often priced lower than Duracell/Energizer in industrial catalogs, making them a hidden gem for facilities management procurement.³¹

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Good (88%). Viewed as a “working man’s” battery.
• Negative Feedback (12%): Availability in tactical channels is low. Users rarely seek them out specifically for WMLs, leading to lower mindshare.

Analyst Verdict: A solid target of opportunity. If an agency has an existing contract with Spectrum Brands or industrial suppliers, these are safe for duty use.

Rank 8: ASP (Armament Systems and Procedures)

Origin: USA (Panasonic Rebrand)

Classification: Tier 1 – Law Enforcement Specialty

Characteristics & Performance:

ASP, known globally for expandable batons and restraints, markets their own branded batteries for their Triad and other duty lights. These are confirmed Made in USA cells.32

• Optimization: ASP claims their cells are optimized for the specific driver characteristics of ASP’s high-drain LED lights.
• Sourcing: Primarily marketed to agencies already buying ASP duty gear, often included as “kit” items.

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Positive (90%).
• Negative Feedback (10%): Scarcity. Hard to find outside of dedicated police supply distributors. Pricing can be high due to the specialized branding.

Analyst Verdict: Reliable and safe, but generally only purchased as an add-on to ASP equipment orders rather than a primary supply source.

Rank 9: Tenergy (Propel)

Origin: China (Tier 1 Import)

Classification: Tier 2 – Safety-Conscious Import

Characteristics & Performance:

Tenergy is a major player in the rechargeable and primary market. Their “Propel” line of CR123A batteries is Chinese-manufactured but distinguishes itself with stated safety features.

• Safety Features: Tenergy explicitly markets the inclusion of a PTC device with a 5 Amp threshold protection.¹⁵ This separates them from generic Chinese “fire” brands that omit this component.
• UL Certification: Their cells carry UL certification, adding a layer of accountability.¹⁵
• Performance: Good, but high-drain performance (sag) is generally higher than Panasonic cells.

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Mixed/Positive (85%). High volume of sales for Arlo camera users.
• Negative Feedback (15%): Some users report shorter lifespans in high-drain tactical lights compared to SureFire. There is confusion in the market between Tenergy’s Li-Ion rechargeable versions and these primary cells.³⁵

Analyst Verdict: A safe “Tier 2” choice. Acceptable for training, admin lights, or perimeter sensors, but US-made cells remain preferred for weapon-mounted applications due to recoil durability.

Rank 10: Titanium Innovations

Origin: China

Classification: Tier 2 – Budget Leader

Characteristics & Performance:

Titanium Innovations (the house brand of BatteryJunction) has established a reputation as the “Best of the Budget” options.

• Performance: They perform surprisingly well in single-cell applications. However, independent testing suggests they exhibit more voltage sag under extreme loads (3A+) than Panasonic cells.³⁷
• Safety: They claim UL certification and RoHS compliance. They are generally considered safe for single-cell lights.
• Cost: Significantly cheaper ($1.00-$1.50 range), making them attractive for high-volume training environments.

Customer Sentiment & TMI:

• Sentiment: Value-Focused (85%).
• Negative Feedback (15%): Reports of lower performance in extreme cold temperatures compared to US cells. Some concerns about using them in expensive night vision gear due to potential leakage risks.³⁷

Analyst Verdict: Acceptable for training, handheld lights, or single-cell applications. NOT recommended for critical duty use in multi-cell series weapon lights due to the higher variance in manufacturing compared to the US Panasonic plant.

---

Note on Exclusions

Varta: Historically a top contender, Varta has shifted much of its consumer battery manufacturing from Germany to China.38 While they remain a reputable brand, the shift in origin removes the “Western Manufacturing” safety guarantee that underpins the top ranks of this report. Consequently, they are excluded from the top tier to maintain the integrity of the safety-focused ranking.

Viridian: While a US company, Viridian’s sourcing is mixed and often laser-focused, placing them as a specialty option rather than a general-purpose tactical standard.40

---

6. The “Flashlight Explosion” Phenomenon: The Danger of Cheap Chinese Batteries

For the electrical engineer or logistics officer, the temptation to cut costs on consumables is high. Generic CR123A batteries from online marketplaces can cost $0.50 per cell, compared to $2.50 for a SureFire. This cost saving is a false economy that introduces a lethal hazard.

6.1 Anatomy of a “Pipe Bomb”: The Failure Mechanism

The danger is rooted in the electrochemical construction of the cell and the willful omission of safety devices in cheap iterations.

6.1.1 Absence of PTC (Positive Temperature Coefficient) Device

The PTC is the primary line of defense against thermal runaway.

• Mechanism: It is a small resistive ring inside the battery header. If current draw becomes excessive (external short circuit) or the cell heats up, the polymer matrix expands, increasing resistance and physically cutting the circuit. It acts as a re-settable thermal fuse.⁷
• The Danger: Cheap Chinese cells often omit the PTC to save manufacturing costs. Under a dead short or thermal runaway event, the battery continues to dump energy until the electrolyte boils and the casing ruptures.

6.1.2 Thin Separators and Recoil-Induced Shorts

• Mechanism: The anode and cathode are rolled into a “jelly roll” separated by a porous membrane (separator).
• The Cheat: To claim higher capacity (e.g., “2000mAh”), cheap manufacturers use thinner separators to pack in more active material.
• The Failure: Under the violent recoil of a firearm (e.g., a 12-gauge shotgun or SCAR-17), the G-force can physically crush this thin separator, causing an internal hard short between the anode and cathode.⁴¹ This triggers immediate, uncontainable thermal runaway inside the weapon light.

6.1.3 Toxic Gas Venting

• Reaction: When a LiMnO2 battery fails, it does not just leak liquid; it vents high-temperature gas. This gas often contains Hydrofluoric Acid (HF).⁷
• Consequence: In a sealed, O-ringed tactical light, the gas cannot escape. Pressure builds until the path of least resistance fails—usually the glass lens or the rubber tail switch.
• Incidents: There are documented cases of LE officers and civilians suffering dental damage, esophageal burns (from inhaling HF gas), and shrapnel wounds from flashlights exploding in their mouths or hands.⁷

6.2 The Series Circuit Hazard (Reverse Charging)

This is the specific scenario that kills devices and injures personnel in 6V (2-battery) systems.

• Scenario: A user loads a 2-cell SureFire light with one fresh generic battery and one partially used generic battery (or two fresh generics with poor QC matching).
• Physics: Under load, the weaker battery reaches 0V first. The stronger battery, still pushing 3V+ and high current, forces electricity through the dead battery in the wrong direction (reverse polarity).
• Reaction: This reverse electrolysis rapidly generates gas and heat within the dead cell. Without a PTC or functional safety vent, the cell deflagrates.⁷
• Conclusion: High-quality US cells (Panasonic) are manufactured with strict capacity matching (binning) to minimize this risk. Cheap cells vary wildly in actual capacity, making series usage dangerous.

---

7. The Rechargeable Dilemma: 16340 vs. CR123A

A growing trend is the use of rechargeable lithium-ion cells (RCR123A or 16340 size) to save money. This presents specific compatibility and safety risks.

7.1 Voltage Mismatch

• CR123A (Primary): Nominal 3.0V. Two in series = 6.0V.
• 16340 (Rechargeable): Nominal 3.6V/3.7V. Fresh off charger = 4.2V. Two in series = 8.4V.
• Risk: Putting two rechargeable 16340s into a light designed for primaries applies 8.4V to a 6V driver. This will instantly fry the electronics of many older SureFire and Streamlight models unless the manufacturer explicitly states “Dual Fuel” compatibility.⁴⁵

7.2 Capacity Deficit

A standard CR123A has ~1500mAh capacity. A standard 16340 rechargeable has only ~650-800mAh.⁴⁵ While rechargeable cells save money, they offer less than half the runtime of primaries, making them a liability for long-duration patrol shifts or field operations where charging infrastructure is absent.

---

8. Risk Profile Data

Table 2: Risk Profile – US vs. Generic Chinese Cells

Feature	US Made (Panasonic OEM)	Generic/Cheap Chinese	Implication
PTC Device	Standard, High Reliability	Often Absent or Low Quality	Fire Risk on Short Circuit
Separator Thickness	Optimized for safety/durability	Optimized for capacity (thin)	Recoil-Induced Internal Short
Voltage Matching	High (Tight Binning)	Low (Wide Variance)	Explosion in Series (2-cell) lights
Venting	Controlled Safety Vents	Unpredictable / Casing Rupture	Shrapnel Hazard
Traceability	Lot Numbers / Dates	Often None	Inventory Management Failure

---

9. Strategic Recommendations for Procurement

For Law Enforcement and Military personnel responsible for equipping forces, the following actions are recommended to mitigate risk and ensure operational readiness:

1. Mandate “Made in USA” Specification: Write procurement requirements to specify “US Manufactured LiMnO2 Primary Cells.” This implicitly forces the vendor to supply Panasonic-sourced cells (SureFire, Streamlight, Duracell, etc.), ensuring the presence of PTC safety devices.
2. Prohibit Mixed Stock: Establish strict SOPs regarding battery replacement.

• Rule: Never mix old and new batteries in a multi-cell light.
• Rule: Never mix brands.
• Rule: When a light dims, replace both cells immediately.

3. Bulk Sourcing: Utilize brands like Battery Station or Streamlight (bulk packs) for training and large-scale issuance. This reduces per-unit costs significantly without sacrificing the Panasonic safety architecture found in retail-packaged SureFire cells.
4. Rechargeable Protocol: If rechargeables (16340s) are introduced to save costs, restrict them to training environments only and ensure lights are marked as compatible. Do not mix rechargeables with primaries in the same device.
5. Avoid “Fire” Brands: Strictly ban the purchase of “Ultrafire,” “Trustfire,” or unbranded blue/white label cells from Amazon/eBay for duty use. The liability cost of a single injury exceeds the lifetime savings of these batteries.

By adhering to these protocols and utilizing the top-ranked brands identified, agencies can ensure that their critical illumination tools remain assets rather than liabilities in the field.

---

Appendix A: Methodology

Ranking Criteria:

The ranking of the Top 10 brands was developed using a multi-variable analysis focusing on mission-critical reliability rather than cost efficiency.

1. OEM Traceability (Weight: 40%):

• Brands were investigated to determine the physical point of manufacture. “Made in USA” cells from the Columbus, GA facility were automatically weighted higher due to the verified presence of PTC safety devices and consistent chemistry. Brands shifting production to China (e.g., Varta) were downgraded or excluded from the top tier.

2. Safety Architecture (Weight: 30%):

• Presence of UL certification, PTC devices, and venting mechanisms.
• Historical data on failure rates and “venting with flame” incidents reported in LE and technical forums (CandlePowerForums, BudgetLightForum).

3. Performance Under Load (Weight: 20%):

• Ability to sustain >2.0V under a 2.0A continuous or pulsed load (simulating high-lumen LED driver requirements).
• Voltage sag characteristics (Internal Resistance).

4. Customer Sentiment & TMI (Weight: 10%):

• Analysis of negative reviews (percentage) focusing on “dead on arrival,” “short life,” or “leakage.”
• Availability of technical data (datasheets) and manufacturer support.

Data Sources:

Data was aggregated from manufacturer Safety Data Sheets (SDS), independent discharge tests (HKJ/Lygte-info, PowerStream), LE officer safety bulletins (FBI/FAA), and verified supply chain origin statements.

---

If you find this post useful, please share the link on Facebook, with your friends, etc. Your support is much appreciated and if you have any feedback, please email me at in**@*********ps.com. Please note that for links to other websites, we are only paid if there is an affiliate program such as Avantlink, Impact, Amazon and eBay and only if you purchase something. If you’d like to directly contribute towards our continued reporting, please visit our funding page.

---

Sources Used

1. Best Batteries For Flashlights In 2025: Reliable Power For Emergencies, accessed November 21, 2025, https://eurocell.co/best-batteries-for-flashlights-in-2025/
2. CR123A vs 123A Batteries Explained for 2025 – Utmel, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.utmel.com/blog/categories/battery/cr123a-vs-123a-batteries-explained-for-2025
3. CR123 vs. CR123A Batteries: How to Choose the Better One? – ariat tech, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.ariat-tech.com/blog/cr123-vs.cr123a-batteries-how-to-choose-the-better-one.html
4. (12) INDIVIDUALLY WRAPPED PANASONIC USA CR123A STREAMLIGHT AND SUREFIRE APPROVED | eBay, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.ebay.com/itm/115914466048
5. Finding olight cr123a battery dealers state-side. : r/flashlight – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/flashlight/comments/hj8w1y/finding_olight_cr123a_battery_dealers_stateside/
6. I have quite a few streamlight weapon lights & am curious what’s everyone’s go to for batteries? (CR123A) Surefire? Streamlight? Another brand I may not heard of? Pls let me know : r/flashlight – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/flashlight/comments/1022mvq/i_have_quite_a_few_streamlight_weapon_lights_am/
7. Exploding Flashlights and How to Protect Yourself – PhotonPhreaks, accessed November 21, 2025, https://photonphreaks.com/exploding-flashlights-and-how-to-prevent-it/
8. What Causes Thermal Runaway? – UL Research Institutes, accessed November 21, 2025, https://ul.org/research-updates/what-causes-thermal-runaway/
9. CR123A – Titanium Innovations, accessed November 21, 2025, https://titaniuminnovations.com/product/cr123a/
10. Test/Review of Panasonic Lithium Power CR123 – BudgetLightForum.com, accessed November 21, 2025, https://budgetlightforum.com/t/test-review-of-panasonic-lithium-power-cr123/21291
11. CR123A Battery: A Comprehensive Guide – Ersa Electronics, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.ersaelectronics.com/blog/cr123a-battery-a-comprehensive-guide
12. Measuring state of charge of a non rechargeable CR123A lithium battery, accessed November 21, 2025, https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/237381/measuring-state-of-charge-of-a-non-rechargeable-cr123a-lithium-battery
13. 5 Reasons Professional Industries Prefer Procell Batteries, accessed November 21, 2025, https://batteryspecialists.com.au/blogs/news/5-reasons-professional-industries-prefer-procell-batteries
14. CR123A 3V Lithium Battery: Specifications, Applications, and Equivalents – Allelco, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.allelcoelec.com/blog/CR123A-3V-Lithium-Battery-Specifications,Applications,and-Equivalents.html
15. 12-pack, Tenergy CR123A Lithium Battery with PTC Protection – [Single Use Non-Rechargeable], accessed November 21, 2025, https://power.tenergy.com/tenergy-lithium-cr123a-3v-non-rechargeable-batteries-w-ptc-12-pack-1-x-card/
16. Best Budget Weapon Lights [Pistol, Rifle & Shotgun] – Pew Pew Tactical, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.pewpewtactical.com/best-budget-weapon-lights/
17. Recommendations for best performing CR123A and/or primaries in general? – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/flashlight/comments/1fe0vwo/recommendations_for_best_performing_cr123a_andor/
18. Anyone use the Surefire 123 batteries? If so, how do they equate to other brands? – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/EDC/comments/18a31gu/anyone_use_the_surefire_123_batteries_if_so_how/
19. Test of Panasonic Lithium Industrial CR123A – Lygte-Info.dk, accessed November 21, 2025, https://lygte-info.dk/review/batteries2012/Panasonic%20Lithium%20Industrial%20CR123A%20UK.html
20. Discharge tests of CR123A lithium manganese dioxide batteries – PowerStream Technology, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.powerstream.com/cr123a-tests.htm
21. 123A Batteries – SureFire, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.surefire.com/123a-batteries/
22. CR123 Batteries (real or fake?) & a Cool Storage Solution – YouTube, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HA_rn2ugXns
23. SFLFP123 Batteries – SureFire, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.surefire.com/sflfp123-batteries/
24. CR123a vs Rechargeable CR123a vs SL-B9 (rechargeable) batteries? : r/flashlight – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/flashlight/comments/1ly6css/cr123a_vs_rechargeable_cr123a_vs_slb9/
25. A Streamlight 85177 CR123A Lithium Batteries Review Won’t Answer These 31 Questions, accessed November 21, 2025, https://backpackinglight.freshdesk.com/support/solutions/articles/14000021503-a-streamlight-85177-cr123a-lithium-batteries-review-won-t-answer-these-31-questions
26. Difference between Duracell Procell Constant and Intense : r/batteries – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/batteries/comments/1btd2p9/difference_between_duracell_procell_constant_and/
27. Lithium CR123 – CR123A – The Battery Station, accessed November 21, 2025, http://www.batterystation.com/cr123a.htm
28. CR123 vs CR123A Battery: Similarities and Differences – Fly-Wing – Flywing Tech, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.flywing-tech.com/blog/cr123-vs-cr123a-battery-whats-the-real-difference/
29. 110 years of history, heritage and innovation – Rayovac Hearing Aid Batteries, accessed November 21, 2025, https://rayovac.eu/110-years-of-history-heritage-and-innovation/
30. Rayovac Photo Lithium Batteries Size 123A 3V, 4 Pack RL123A-4 – Best Buy, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.bestbuy.com/product/rayovac-photo-lithium-batteries-size-123a-3v-4-pack/J7CCPKL52C
31. RL123A-1G, Photo Lithium Carded 123A 1-Pack, 3.0 Volt (6 packs/case), accessed November 21, 2025, https://rayovacindustrial.com/products/specialty-batteries/lithium-photo-batteries/specialty-batteries-lithium-photo-batteries-rl123a1-photo-lithium-carded-123a-1-pack/
32. ASP Lithium CR123A Batteries, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.asp-usa.com/products/cr123a-asp-lithium
33. 4PK- INDIVIDUALLY SEALED PANASONIC USA CR123A BATTERY APPROVED BY STREAMLIGHT | eBay, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.ebay.com/itm/115340238005
34. Tenergy Propel 3V CR123A Lithium Battery, High Performance CR123A Cell Batteries PTC Protected for Cameras, Flashlight Replacement CR123A Batteries, 20-Pack (Not For Arlo Camera) – Walmart, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.walmart.com/ip/Tenergy-Propel-3V-CR123A-Lithium-Battery-High-Performance-CR123A-Cell-Batteries-PTC-Protected-Cameras-Flashlight-Replacement-CR123A-Batteries-20-Pack/935326149
35. Tenergy CR123 rechargeable batteries/charger review – Arlo Community, accessed November 21, 2025, https://community.arlo.com/t5/Arlo/Tenergy-CR123-rechargeable-batteries-charger-review/td-p/1358364
36. Plenty of Battery confusion ARLO wireless camera – Arlo Community, accessed November 21, 2025, https://community.arlo.com/t5/Arlo/Plenty-of-Battery-confusion-ARLO-wireless-camera/td-p/1523768
37. Performance difference noted in Titanium Innovations CR123 – BudgetLightForum.com, accessed November 21, 2025, https://budgetlightforum.com/t/performance-difference-noted-in-titanium-innovations-cr123/68581
38. are VARTA batteries made in china now !!? I am really worried they may be fake – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/batteries/comments/1b92y3c/are_varta_batteries_made_in_china_now_i_am_really/
39. are VARTA made in china now !!? I am really worried they may be fake – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/avoidchineseproducts/comments/1b92kwc/are_varta_made_in_china_now_i_am_really_worried/
40. Viridian Weapon Technologies Tactical Energy+ CR123A Lithium Battery – 3-Pack, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.opticsplanet.com/viridian-tactical-energy-cr123-3v-lithium-batteries.html
41. How to select the right battery separator, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.battery-component.com/how-to-select-the-right-battery-separator.html
42. What Is Thermal Runaway and How Can You Prevent It? – R&D Batteries, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.rdbatteries.com/blog/post/what-is-thermal-runaway.html
43. Potential hazard with CR123 Batteries – Backpacking Light, accessed November 21, 2025, https://backpackinglight.com/forums/topic/10731/
44. INTELLIGENCE BULLETIN (U) Counterfeit and Substandard Lithium (CR123A) Power Cell Batteries Pose Serious Health and Safety Risks, accessed November 21, 2025, https://info.publicintelligence.net/FBI-LithiumBatteries.pdf
45. 16340 vs CR123A: Are we all using the WRONG battery in our flashlights? – Smart.DHgate, accessed November 21, 2025, https://smart.dhgate.com/16340-vs-cr123a-are-we-all-using-the-wrong-battery-in-our-flashlights/
46. CR123A Battery Guide: Specs, Compatible Models & Buying Tips – Bettlink, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.bettlink.com/blog/cr123a-battery-guide-specs-compatible-models-tips
47. What cr123 batteries are you guys using ? In currently on a Duracell set after terrible luck with surefire batteries. – Reddit, accessed November 21, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/flashlight/comments/f8zrr4/what_cr123_batteries_are_you_guys_using_in/
48. Test of Olight 16340 RCR123A 650mAH (Cyan) – Lygte-Info.dk, accessed November 21, 2025, https://lygte-info.dk/review/batteries2012/Olight%2016340%20RCR123A%20650mAH%20(Cyan)%20UK.html