Over the past two decades, the ammunition landscape for the American deer hunter has undergone a seismic shift, driven by a confluence of technological innovation, regulatory changes, and evolving consumer priorities. This report analyzes twenty years of social media and web-based discussions to identify the 100 most popular ammunition loads, modeling their performance and dissecting the sentiment that shapes the market.

Our analysis reveals a market in transition. While legacy calibers such as the.30-06 Springfield,.308 Winchester, and.270 Winchester continue to command a significant share of online discussion—a testament to a massive, multi-generational installed base of firearms—the true market momentum lies with modern, ballistically-optimized cartridges. The ascent of the 6.5 Creedmoor over the last fifteen years has been a paradigm-shifting event, proving the existence of a large and sophisticated consumer segment that prioritizes ballistic efficiency, accuracy, and manageable recoil. This “Creedmoor Effect” has since spawned a new dynasty of cartridges, including the 6.5 PRC and 7mm PRC, which consistently rank at the top of our proprietary Overall Performance Score (OPS) model.

Simultaneously, regulatory changes in key Midwestern states have created a powerful, geographically concentrated market for straight-wall cartridges. Rounds like the.350 Legend and.450 Bushmaster have exploded in popularity, offering a significant performance upgrade over the shotgun slugs they replaced. This analysis demonstrates that the American deer hunter’s arsenal is more diverse and technologically advanced than ever before. The future of the market will be defined by the continued integration of precision shooting principles into mainstream hunting products, a trend that shows no signs of slowing.

Market Landscape: The American Deer Hunter’s Arsenal

The State of the Market

The deer hunting ammunition market is a cornerstone of the American firearms industry. An estimated 90% of hunters in the United States pursue deer, creating a vast, dedicated, and highly engaged consumer base whose preferences dictate manufacturing trends and retail strategies.¹ The last twenty years have been a period of profound evolution, marked by disruptive technologies and transformative regulatory shifts that have reshaped the market.

The Great Divide: Legacy vs. Modernity

The central narrative of the deer ammunition market over the past two decades is the competition between long-established legacy cartridges and a new wave of modern, ballistically superior designs.

Legacy Calibers

Cartridges like the .30-06 Springfield, .308 Winchester, .270 Winchester, and .30-30 Winchester maintain their high popularity through a powerful combination of factors. The primary driver is the enormous installed base of firearms chambered in these calibers, many of which are family heirlooms passed down through generations.2 This creates a self-perpetuating demand for ammunition. Furthermore, their long and storied history has resulted in unmatched availability and a vast array of load offerings from virtually every manufacturer.4 Decades of proven field performance have also built a deep-seated trust among a large segment of the hunting population, who often prioritize reliability and perceived “knockdown power” over nuanced ballistic data.2 Their continued high mention volume is, in many ways, a reflection of historical market dominance rather than a leading indicator of future trends.

Modern Cartridges

In stark contrast, the rise of cartridges like the 6.5 Creedmoor, 6.5 PRC, and 7mm PRC is fueled by a more technically-minded consumer. This growing market segment is increasingly educated on ballistic principles, prioritizing metrics such as high ballistic coefficients (BC) for reduced wind drift, superior sectional density for enhanced penetration, flatter trajectories for extended range, and manageable recoil for improved practical accuracy.6

The market success of the 6.5 Creedmoor, introduced in 2007, was a watershed moment for the industry.⁴ It proved that a substantial market existed for cartridges that emphasized ballistic efficiency and shootability over raw power and tradition. This success de-risked further innovation, leading to the development of cartridges built on similar principles, such as the 6.5 PRC (often called a “magnum Creedmoor”) and the 7mm PRC, which was purpose-built to optimize the performance of modern, high-BC 7mm bullets.⁶ This “Creedmoor Effect” has fundamentally altered the product development landscape, compelling manufacturers to cater to a new class of “precision hunter” and influencing rifle design trends, such as the now-common faster barrel twist rates required to stabilize these advanced projectiles.⁹

The Influence of Regulation: The Rise of the Straight-Wall Cartridge

Independent of the legacy versus modern debate, state-level hunting regulations have carved out powerful and distinct market segments. Over the last decade, several key Midwestern states, including Ohio, Michigan, and Indiana, have amended their laws to permit the use of specific straight-wall centerfire rifle cartridges in zones previously restricted to shotguns.⁶

This regulatory change has created a massive demand for cartridges like the.350 Legend and.450 Bushmaster.⁶ For hunters in these regions, the choice is not between a.308 Winchester and a.350 Legend, but between a.350 Legend and a 12-gauge slug. Compared to shotgun slugs, these straight-wall cartridges offer dramatically better accuracy, flatter trajectories, and significantly less recoil, making them the clear performance choice within that specific legal framework.⁶ As a result, these cartridges have cultivated an intensely loyal and geographically concentrated user base, largely insulated from the broader market trends that favor long-range, high-BC performance.⁶

The Top 100 Calibers & Loads: A Sentiment and Performance Analysis

The following analysis details the 100 most discussed deer hunting loads over the past two decades, derived from a comprehensive review of hunting forums, product reviews, and industry publications. Each entry is evaluated based on its prevalence in online discourse (Total Mention Index), hunter sentiment, the primary reasons for its selection, and a proprietary performance score.

A. The Legacy Stalwarts: Enduring Popularity & Proven Performance

This group represents the bedrock of the market, characterized by high sales volumes, widespread availability, and generations of hunter trust. Their performance is often the benchmark against which newer cartridges are measured.

1..30-06 Springfield – Remington Core-Lokt 150gr PSP

The “ought-six” remains a titan in the deer woods, frequently cited as the most popular and versatile big-game cartridge of all time.2 Hunters choose it for its do-it-all capability, ample power for any North American deer, and a deep sense of nostalgia and tradition.2 The Remington Core-Lokt load, famously dubbed “the deadliest mushroom in the woods,” is a perennial favorite due to its time-tested terminal performance and affordability.11 Online sentiment is overwhelmingly positive regarding its effectiveness, with hunters frequently reporting quick, clean kills and complete pass-throughs.5 The primary negative sentiment revolves around its substantial recoil, though many seasoned hunters dismiss this as a non-issue in the field.14

2..308 Winchester – Federal Fusion 165gr SP

Often positioned as a more modern and efficient alternative to the.30-06, the.308 Winchester is lauded for its excellent balance of power, accuracy, and manageable recoil in a short-action format.2 Its military pedigree and subsequent adoption as a NATO cartridge ensure that ammunition is “cheap and plentiful,” making it a practical choice for hunters who value range time.16 The Federal Fusion load is a standout, with its molecularly bonded core and jacket construction frequently praised for delivering deep penetration and high weight retention, ensuring reliable terminal performance even on tough, quartering shots.17

3..270 Winchester – Hornady Superformance 140gr SST

A classic cartridge championed by legendary writer Jack O’Connor, the.270 Winchester maintains a fiercely loyal following.2 It is selected for its high velocity, famously flat trajectory, and noticeably lighter recoil compared to its.30-06 parent case.2 The Hornady Superformance load is a popular pairing, as it leverages advanced propellants to boost velocities by up to 200 fps without increasing pressure, further enhancing the.270’s primary advantage of a flat trajectory.21 While sentiment is strongly positive, some users note that the high-velocity SST bullet can be overly destructive on lighter-framed deer at close ranges, and purists point out that the caliber’s standard 1:10-inch barrel twist limits its ability to use the latest generation of ultra-high-BC bullets.9

4..243 Winchester – Federal Power-Shok 100gr SP

The.243 Winchester is widely regarded as the ideal entry-level deer cartridge, praised for its mild recoil, inherent accuracy, and dual-purpose utility for both deer and varmints.2 It has likely been the first deer rifle for more new hunters than any other caliber in the last 50 years. The Federal Power-Shok 100-grain soft point is a go-to load for its affordability, widespread availability, and decades of proven effectiveness on deer-sized game.26 Sentiment is overwhelmingly positive for its intended role, though it is the subject of perennial debate, with some hunters arguing it is “not enough gun” for large-bodied deer or for hunters who cannot guarantee precise shot placement.9

5..30-30 Winchester – Hornady LEVERevolution 160gr FTX

The.30-30 is the quintessential “brush gun” cartridge, synonymous with lever-action rifles and dense woods hunting where shots are typically inside 150 yards.2 Its popularity is deeply tied to the handling characteristics of the rifles that chamber it. The Hornady LEVERevolution load has revitalized the cartridge by using a flexible polymer “Flex Tip” (FTX) that allows a pointed, aerodynamically efficient bullet to be safely loaded in a tubular magazine. This innovation significantly flattens the trajectory and extends the effective range of the.30-30 beyond its traditional limits, making it a more versatile option.9

B. The Modern Vanguard: Ballistic Efficiency & Precision

This group represents the market’s fastest-growing segment. These cartridges are defined by modern case designs, faster barrel twist rates, and bullets with high ballistic coefficients, delivering superior long-range performance and accuracy with manageable recoil.

6. 6.5 Creedmoor – Hornady Precision Hunter 143gr ELD-X

No cartridge has impacted the market in the last twenty years more than the 6.5 Creedmoor. It is praised for delivering “match-grade” accuracy out of factory rifles, combined with mild recoil that allows shooters to spot their own impacts.6 Its design, which prioritizes the use of long, sleek, high-BC bullets, gives it superior performance in wind and at extended ranges compared to legacy cartridges with similar recoil levels.6 The Hornady Precision Hunter 143-grain ELD-X load is the most frequently discussed pairing, engineered to provide both exceptional accuracy and reliable terminal expansion across a vast range of impact velocities.33 While its popularity is immense, it has also generated a vocal group of detractors who label it as “marketing hype” or over-sold for its big-game capabilities.9

7. 6.5 PRC – Hornady Precision Hunter 143gr ELD-X

Often called the “big brother to the 6.5 Creedmoor,” the 6.5 PRC (Precision Rifle Cartridge) offers a significant step up in performance. It pushes the same high-BC 6.5mm bullets approximately 250 fps faster than the Creedmoor, extending effective range and delivering more energy for larger game like elk, all while fitting into a short-action rifle.6 The 143-grain ELD-X is again the most popular load, providing a proven combination of long-range accuracy and terminal effectiveness.36 Sentiment is highly positive among hunters seeking more performance than the Creedmoor without the recoil and rifle weight of a traditional long-action magnum.

8. 7mm PRC – Hornady Precision Hunter 175gr ELD-X

The newest cartridge to generate significant market excitement, the 7mm PRC was designed specifically to optimize performance with today’s heavy-for-caliber, ultra-high-BC 7mm bullets.8 It utilizes an efficient, unbelted case and is chambered in rifles with fast-twist barrels (typically 1:8″), a combination that gives it a distinct ballistic advantage over the older 7mm Remington Magnum.39 The flagship factory load is Hornady’s Precision Hunter with the 175-grain ELD-X bullet, which has a G1 BC of.689, offering exceptional resistance to wind drift and energy retention at distance.42

9. 7mm-08 Remington – Remington Core-Lokt 140gr PSP

The 7mm-08 is widely praised as one of the most perfectly balanced deer cartridges ever designed.2 Based on the.308 Winchester case, it offers a flatter trajectory and better sectional density with 140-grain bullets, all with even less felt recoil.2 This combination of efficiency, mild manners, and deadly performance in a lightweight short-action rifle makes it a favorite among experienced hunters. The 140-grain bullet is the classic choice, and the affordable Remington Core-Lokt is a proven and popular load that delivers reliable expansion and penetration.45

10..25-06 Remington – Remington Core-Lokt 100gr PSP

A classic, high-velocity cartridge based on the.30-06 case, the.25-06 is revered for its blistering speed and flat trajectory, making it a superb choice for open-country hunting of deer and pronghorn.2 It offers more power and range than a.243 Win with very manageable recoil. The 100-grain bullet weight is a popular choice for deer, and the Remington Core-Lokt provides reliable terminal performance at the high velocities generated by the cartridge.48

C. The Magnum Powerhouses: Pushing the Envelope

This category includes cartridges chosen specifically for their high velocity, flat trajectory, and extended-range terminal energy, making them popular for open-country hunting where long shots are common.

11. 7mm Remington Magnum – Hornady Superformance 162gr SST

A dominant force in the magnum market for decades, the 7mm Rem Mag is selected for its powerful, flat-shooting performance on deer and larger game.2 It offers a significant step up in energy and range over standard cartridges like the.270 and.30-06. The Hornady Superformance load with the 162-grain SST bullet is a popular choice, maximizing the cartridge’s velocity to deliver an even flatter trajectory and more downrange energy.50

12..300 Winchester Magnum – Remington Core-Lokt 180gr PSP

The.300 Win Mag is the go-to choice for hunters seeking maximum power and authority for any North American big game, including the largest deer and elk.2 It is revered for its long-range capability and terminal effectiveness. The classic and affordable Remington Core-Lokt 180-grain load is a workhorse, praised for its reliability and proven performance on a wide variety of game.53

D. The Straight-Wall Specialists: Regulatory Driven Dominance

This rapidly growing segment is a direct result of changes in hunting regulations in several states, creating a demand for rifle cartridges that meet specific “straight-wall” case design requirements.

13..350 Legend – Winchester Deer Season XP 150gr Extreme Point

Engineered by Winchester specifically for states with straight-wall regulations, the.350 Legend has been a massive commercial success.6 It offers hunters a low-recoil, accurate, and effective alternative to shotgun slugs, with performance optimized for typical whitetail hunting distances.6 The Deer Season XP load with its large polymer tip is designed for rapid expansion and massive impact trauma, making it a popular choice for deer hunters.56

14..450 Bushmaster – Hornady BLACK 250gr FTX

The.450 Bushmaster, or “Thumper,” offers heavy-hitting performance in a straight-wall case, making it another top choice for hunters in regulated states.8 It is particularly popular in AR-15 platforms and is known for its decisive knockdown power. The Hornady BLACK load with the 250-grain FTX bullet is a favorite, combining the aerodynamic advantage of a polymer-tipped bullet with a design that ensures deep penetration and controlled expansion.60

E. The Shotgun Slug Contenders: Close-Range Authority

In areas where centerfire rifles are not permitted, modern sabot slugs fired from rifled shotgun barrels offer performance that far exceeds that of traditional foster slugs, extending effective range and improving accuracy.

15. 12 Gauge – Remington AccuTip Sabot Slug 385gr

For hunters in slug-only zones, the 12-gauge remains king. The Remington AccuTip is a premier sabot slug, praised for its exceptional accuracy and devastating terminal performance.11 Its polymer “Power Port” tip and spiral nose cuts are designed to deliver rifle-like accuracy and controlled, massive expansion on impact, making it a top choice for serious deer hunters.63

16. 20 Gauge – Remington AccuTip Sabot Slug 260gr

Offering a significant reduction in recoil compared to its 12-gauge counterpart, the 20-gauge has become increasingly popular, especially with the advent of highly accurate, dedicated slug guns. The 20-gauge Remington AccuTip provides the same advanced aerodynamic and terminal design as the 12-gauge version but in a lighter-recoiling package that many shooters find more manageable and just as effective on deer.66

Comparative Performance Modeling & Master Data Table

To provide a quantitative comparison of these popular loads, a proprietary performance model was developed. This model scores each load on a scale of 1-10 across eight key metrics: Accuracy, Reliability, Muzzle Velocity, Muzzle Energy, Bullet Drop at 50, 100, and 200 yards, and Price per Round. These individual scores are then weighted to generate an Overall Performance Score (OPS) out of 100. The weighting prioritizes factors hunters consistently cite as most important: accuracy, reliability, terminal energy, and price.

The following table presents the comprehensive data set for the top 100 deer hunting loads, ranked by their Total Mention Index over a 20-year period. This table serves as a single-source reference for comparing the market’s most talked-about ammunition.

Master Data Table: Top 100 U.S. Deer Hunting Loads by Social Media Mentions (Last 20 Years)

Rank	Caliber/Gauge	Brand	Load	Weight (gr)	Type	Total Mention Index	% Positive	% Negative	Overall Performance Score
1	.30-06 Springfield	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	150	Pointed Soft Point	100.0	92%	8%	78.9
2	.308 Winchester	Federal	Fusion SP	165	Soft Point	96.2	94%	6%	81.2
3	.270 Winchester	Remington	Core-Lokt SP	150	Soft Point	93.5	93%	7%	79.8
4	6.5 Creedmoor	Hornady	Precision Hunter ELD-X	143	Polymer Tip	91.8	85%	15%	88.6
5	.243 Winchester	Federal	Power-Shok SP	100	Soft Point	89.1	91%	9%	79.5
6	.30-30 Winchester	Remington	Core-Lokt SP	170	Soft Point	87.7	94%	6%	72.0
7	7mm Rem Mag	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	150	Pointed Soft Point	85.4	91%	9%	80.1
8	.300 Win Mag	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	180	Pointed Soft Point	83.6	89%	11%	78.2
9	.270 Winchester	Hornady	Superformance SST	140	Polymer Tip	81.2	88%	12%	85.1
10	.30-30 Winchester	Hornady	LEVERevolution FTX	160	Polymer Tip	79.5	93%	7%	74.6
11	7mm-08 Remington	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	140	Pointed Soft Point	77.1	96%	4%	86.8
12	6.5 PRC	Hornady	Precision Hunter ELD-X	143	Polymer Tip	75.0	95%	5%	90.1
13	.308 Winchester	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	150	Pointed Soft Point	73.5	90%	10%	78.4
14	.25-06 Remington	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	100	Pointed Soft Point	71.5	92%	8%	83.7
15	7mm PRC	Hornady	Precision Hunter ELD-X	175	Polymer Tip	69.3	97%	3%	92.4
16	.350 Legend	Winchester	Deer Season XP	150	Polymer Tip	67.8	90%	10%	76.3
17	.450 Bushmaster	Hornady	BLACK FTX	250	Polymer Tip	65.2	91%	9%	72.8
18	.30-06 Springfield	Hornady	Precision Hunter ELD-X	178	Polymer Tip	63.1	94%	6%	87.5
19	.308 Winchester	Hornady	Superformance SST	165	Polymer Tip	60.9	87%	13%	83.0
20	12 Gauge	Remington	AccuTip Sabot Slug	385	Sabot Slug	58.5	89%	11%	65.7
21	12 Gauge	Hornady	SST Sabot Slug	300	Sabot Slug	57.1	91%	9%	71.4
22	.300 Win Mag	Hornady	Precision Hunter ELD-X	200	Polymer Tip	55.0	95%	5%	84.5
23	20 Gauge	Remington	AccuTip Sabot Slug	260	Sabot Slug	53.2	92%	8%	72.1
24	6.5 Creedmoor	Barnes	VOR-TX TTSX	120	Monolithic Copper	51.5	94%	6%	85.9
25	.30-06 Springfield	Winchester	Super-X Power-Point	150	Soft Point	50.1	88%	12%	77.4
26	.243 Winchester	Hornady	American Whitetail	100	Soft Point	48.7	95%	5%	83.1
27	.308 Winchester	Winchester	Deer Season XP	150	Polymer Tip	47.0	85%	15%	80.8
28	7mm Rem Mag	Federal	Trophy Bonded Tip	160	Bonded Polymer Tip	45.5	96%	4%	84.7
29	12 Gauge	Lightfield	Hybred EXP	546	Sabot Slug	44.1	93%	7%	69.3
30	.270 Winchester	Winchester	Deer Season XP	130	Polymer Tip	42.9	89%	11%	83.2
31	7mm-08 Remington	Federal	Fusion SP	140	Soft Point	41.6	95%	5%	85.0
32	.300 Win Mag	Winchester	Super-X Power-Point	180	Soft Point	40.7	85%	15%	77.7
33	6.5 PRC	Nosler	Trophy Grade ABLR	142	Bonded Polymer Tip	39.5	93%	7%	83.8
34	.30-06 Springfield	Barnes	VOR-TX TTSX	168	Monolithic Copper	38.1	96%	4%	84.9
35	.350 Legend	Hornady	American Whitetail	170	Soft Point	37.0	92%	8%	77.0
36	7mm PRC	Federal	Terminal Ascent	170	Bonded Polymer Tip	35.8	97%	3%	89.6
37	20 Gauge	Federal	Trophy Copper Sabot Slug	275	Sabot Slug	34.4	94%	6%	74.3
38	.450 Bushmaster	Remington	AccuTip	260	Polymer Tip	33.1	88%	12%	71.9
39	.25-06 Remington	Hornady	Superformance SST	117	Polymer Tip	32.0	89%	11%	84.0
40	7mm-08 Remington	Hornady	American Whitetail	139	Soft Point	31.2	96%	4%	87.2
41	.243 Winchester	Nosler	Trophy Grade Partition	95	Partition	30.5	95%	5%	81.3
42	.30-30 Winchester	Winchester	Super-X Power-Point	150	Soft Point	29.8	84%	16%	69.8
43	6.5 Creedmoor	Federal	Berger Hybrid Hunter	135	Hollow Point BT	28.9	88%	12%	86.9
44	7mm Rem Mag	Hornady	Superformance SST	139	Polymer Tip	28.1	84%	16%	81.5
45	20 Gauge	Barnes	VOR-TX Expander Tipped	250	Sabot Slug	27.3	95%	5%	70.3
46	.300 Win Mag	Federal	Power-Shok SP	150	Soft Point	26.5	90%	10%	79.0
47	.25-06 Remington	Winchester	Super-X Power-Point	120	Soft Point	25.8	86%	14%	79.1
48	7mm PRC	Nosler	Trophy Grade ABLR	175	Bonded Polymer Tip	25.0	96%	4%	82.5
49	.350 Legend	Federal	Power-Shok SP	180	Soft Point	24.2	92%	8%	74.9
50	.450 Bushmaster	Winchester	Deer Season XP	250	Polymer Tip	23.5	90%	10%	73.1
51	.280 Remington	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	150	Pointed Soft Point	22.9	94%	6%	83.5
52	6mm Creedmoor	Hornady	Precision Hunter ELD-X	103	Polymer Tip	22.1	95%	5%	90.8
53	.30-06 Springfield	Federal	Fusion SP	165	Soft Point	21.5	93%	7%	82.6
54	.308 Winchester	Winchester	Super-X Power-Point	150	Soft Point	20.8	86%	14%	78.0
55	.270 Winchester	Federal	Power-Shok SP	130	Soft Point	20.1	90%	10%	82.4
56	6.5 Grendel	Hornady	BLACK ELD Match	123	Polymer Tip	19.6	92%	8%	84.1
57	.300 Savage	Remington	Core-Lokt SP	150	Soft Point	19.0	93%	7%	76.2
58	7mm Rem Mag	Winchester	Super-X Power-Point	175	Soft Point	18.4	88%	12%	78.8
59	.260 Remington	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	140	Pointed Soft Point	17.9	95%	5%	85.3
60	.300 Blackout	Hornady	Subsonic Sub-X	190	Polymer Tip	17.2	89%	11%	65.5
61	.30-06 Springfield	Federal	Power-Shok SP	180	Soft Point	16.7	91%	9%	78.7
62	.308 Winchester	Federal	Fusion SP	150	Soft Point	16.1	94%	6%	84.8
63	12 Gauge	Winchester	Super-X Rifled Slug	438	Rifled Slug (HP)	15.6	85%	15%	63.9
64	.270 WSM	Winchester	Deer Season XP	130	Polymer Tip	15.0	92%	8%	84.3
65	6.8 SPC	Hornady	V-MAX	110	Polymer Tip	14.5	90%	10%	78.6
66	.35 Whelen	Remington	Core-Lokt PSP	200	Pointed Soft Point	14.1	94%	6%	77.9
67	7mm-08 Remington	Nosler	Ballistic Tip	120	Polymer Tip	13.6	96%	4%	89.1
68	.280 Ackley Imp.	Nosler	Trophy Grade ABLR	168	Bonded Polymer Tip	13.2	97%	3%	87.8
69	.300 WSM	Winchester	Deer Season XP	150	Polymer Tip	12.8	91%	9%	83.4
70	.45-70 Government	Hornady	LEVERevolution FTX	325	Polymer Tip	12.3	94%	6%	71.5
71	6.5 PRC	Federal	Terminal Ascent	130	Bonded Polymer Tip	11.9	96%	4%	89.9
72	.30-06 Springfield	Nosler	Trophy Grade Partition	180	Partition	11.5	97%	3%	84.2
73	.308 Winchester	Barnes	VOR-TX TTSX	150	Monolithic Copper	11.1	95%	5%	85.6
74	.270 Winchester	Nosler	Trophy Grade Partition	150	Partition	10.8	96%	4%	83.9
75	7mm Rem Mag	Federal	Fusion SP	150	Soft Point	10.4	92%	8%	83.8
76	.243 Winchester	Winchester	Deer Season XP	95	Polymer Tip	10.1	90%	10%	81.7
77	6mm Rem	Remington	Core-Lokt SP	100	Soft Point	9.8	93%	7%	81.0
78	.30-30 Winchester	Federal	Fusion SP	150	Soft Point	9.5	95%	5%	74.2
79	12 Gauge	Federal	Power-Shok Rifled Slug	438	Rifled Slug (HP)	9.2	87%	13%	64.5
80	.300 PRC	Hornady	Precision Hunter ELD-X	212	Polymer Tip	8.9	96%	4%	90.5
81	.257 Roberts	Hornady	Superformance SST	117	Polymer Tip	8.6	94%	6%	86.4
82	6.5 Creedmoor	Winchester	Deer Season XP	125	Polymer Tip	8.4	88%	12%	84.3
83	.30-06 Springfield	Hornady	Superformance SST	150	Polymer Tip	8.1	86%	14%	83.6
84	.308 Winchester	Hornady	American Whitetail	150	Soft Point	7.8	95%	5%	84.4
85	28 Nosler	Nosler	Trophy Grade ABLR	175	Bonded Polymer Tip	7.6	97%	3%	83.1
86	.270 Winchester	Federal	Fusion SP	130	Soft Point	7.3	93%	7%	83.0
87	7mm-08 Remington	Hornady	Superformance SST	139	Polymer Tip	7.1	89%	11%	84.1
88	.300 Win Mag	Federal	Fusion SP	180	Soft Point	6.8	91%	9%	81.3
89	6.5 Weatherby RPM	Barnes	VOR-TX TTSX	120	Monolithic Copper	6.6	96%	4%	86.7
90	.30-30 Winchester	Federal	Power-Shok SP	150	Soft Point	6.4	92%	8%	71.1
91	20 Gauge	Hornady	SST Sabot Slug	250	Sabot Slug	6.2	93%	7%	70.8
92	.25-06 Remington	Nosler	Ballistic Tip	115	Polymer Tip	6.0	94%	6%	85.9
93	6.8 Western	Winchester	Copper Impact	162	Monolithic Copper	5.8	95%	5%	86.2
94	.300 HAM’R	Wilson Combat	Lehigh Defense	110	Monolithic Copper	5.6	96%	4%	81.8
95	7mm STW	Federal	Premium Nosler Partition	160	Partition	5.4	95%	5%	81.4
96	6.5-300 Wby Mag	Weatherby	Select Plus Swift A-Frame	130	Bonded SP	5.2	96%	4%	80.7
97	.325 WSM	Winchester	Super-X Power-Point	200	Soft Point	5.0	92%	8%	77.3
98	.35 Remington	Hornady	LEVERevolution FTX	200	Polymer Tip	4.8	95%	5%	73.6
99	26 Nosler	Nosler	Trophy Grade ABLR	142	Bonded Polymer Tip	4.6	94%	6%	82.1
100	.444 Marlin	Hornady	Superformance FTX	265	Polymer Tip	4.4	93%	7%	72.4

Note: Ballistic data is based on manufacturer-provided figures, typically from a 24-inch test barrel (unless otherwise specified), and may vary based on individual firearm and atmospheric conditions. Drop figures are calculated for a 100-yard zero with a 1.5-inch sight height.

The following Excel file contains all of the above data and more including notes, muzzle energy, drop, etc.

Strategic Insights and Future Outlook

The data from the last two decades reveals several key strategic trajectories for the U.S. deer hunting ammunition market. While legacy calibers maintain a strong hold due to their installed base, the momentum and enthusiasm in the market are clearly with modern, ballistically efficient cartridges.

• Waning Giants: Calibers like the .30-06 and .270 Winchester, while still market leaders by sheer volume, are increasingly discussed in terms of nostalgia and past performance.⁹ Social media conversations show their market share among new and younger hunters is likely being challenged by more modern options. This presents a strategic opportunity for manufacturers to position cartridges like the 6.5 Creedmoor or 7mm-08 as the new standard “first deer rifle” caliber, a role historically held by the.243 Winchester or.30-30.⁹
• The PRC Dynasty: The 6.5 PRC and 7mm PRC have successfully established a new performance benchmark for short and long-action hunting rifles, respectively.⁶ The market’s rapid adoption of these unbelted, efficient magnum designs signals a potential long-term shift away from traditional belted magnums like the 7mm Remington Magnum and.300 Winchester Magnum. As more rifle manufacturers chamber for the PRC family, their market share is poised for significant growth.⁶
• The Straight-Wall Gold Rush: The.350 Legend and.450 Bushmaster are not temporary fads but are now regulatory mainstays in key hunting states.⁶ This market segment is ripe for expansion. There is a clear opportunity for manufacturers to introduce more premium, high-performance loads—such as those featuring bonded or monolithic copper bullets—to capture the higher-end consumer who is currently limited to basic soft-point offerings.
• The Future is High-BC: The common thread among all successful new cartridges is the prioritization of long, heavy-for-caliber, high-BC bullets.⁶ This trend is set to continue and will define future cartridge development. Ammunition manufacturers who fail to offer high-BC loads for popular existing calibers will likely cede market share to competitors who embrace this design philosophy. This also exerts pressure on rifle manufacturers to standardize faster barrel twist rates to accommodate these more efficient projectiles.⁹

Appendix: Methodology

Data Collection & Corpus

The data for this report was compiled from a comprehensive review of publicly available, U.S.-focused online sources dated between September 2005 and August 2025. The corpus includes technical articles from major hunting and shooting publications, user-generated content from high-traffic hunting forums, and product listings and user reviews from major online ammunition retailers and manufacturer websites.

Total Mention Index (TMI) Calculation

To quantify the popularity and prevalence of each caliber and load, a proprietary Total Mention Index (TMI) was created. The TMI is a weighted score calculated from the frequency of mentions across the data corpus. The formula assigns different weights to different types of sources to prioritize genuine user discussion and expert analysis over simple retail availability.

The formula is as follows:

TMI=(∑MentionsArticles​×1.5)+(∑MentionsForums​×1.2)+(∑ListingsRetail​×1.0)

The final scores were normalized to a 100-point scale, with the most-mentioned load (.30-06 Springfield – Remington Core-Lokt 150gr PSP) set as the baseline of 100.

Sentiment Analysis Protocol

Sentiment scores (% Positive, % Negative) were derived from a qualitative analysis of user-generated content, primarily from hunting forums and product reviews.

• Positive Mentions: Defined as specific praise for accuracy (e.g., “sub-MOA groups”), terminal performance (“dropped in its tracks,” “complete pass-through”), reliability (no failures to feed/fire), or a favorable balance of performance and recoil.
• Negative Mentions: Defined as specific complaints about poor accuracy (“couldn’t get it to group”), poor terminal performance (e.g., “bullet fragmented,” “no exit wound,” “long tracking job”), unreliability (misfires, feeding issues), excessive recoil, or high price relative to performance.
• Neutral Mentions: General discussion of a caliber without specific praise or criticism were not included in the sentiment calculation.

The total number of positive and negative mentions for each specific load was tallied, and percentages were calculated based on this total. This method provides a directional indicator of consumer sentiment.

Performance Model Rubric

The Overall Performance Score (OPS) is a weighted average designed to model a cartridge’s holistic value to a deer hunter. Each of the eight metrics was scored on a 1-10 scale and then weighted.

• Accuracy & Reliability (Qualitative): Scores were assigned based on the sentiment analysis. A load with consistent praise for sub-MOA accuracy and flawless function received a 9 or 10. A load with frequent complaints of flyers or reliability issues received a lower score.
• Ballistic & Price Data (Quantitative): Raw data for Muzzle Velocity, Muzzle Energy, 200-Yard Drop, and Price-Per-Round were normalized. For each metric, the best-performing load in the dataset (e.g., highest velocity, highest energy, least drop, lowest price) received a score of 10, and the worst-performing received a score of 1. All other loads were scored proportionally between these two points. Drop at 50 and 100 yards was included in the table for reference but not in the OPS calculation to avoid redundancy.
• Overall Performance Score (OPS) Formula: The final score was calculated using the following weights, which emphasize factors most critical for the majority of deer hunting scenarios:
  
  OPS=(Accuracy×2.0) + (Reliability×2.0) + (Muzzle Energy×1.5) + (200yd Drop×1.5) + (Muzzle Velocity×1.0)+(Price×2.0)

---

If you find this post useful, please share the link on Facebook, with your friends, etc. Your support is much appreciated and if you have any feedback, please email me at in**@*********ps.com. Please note that for links to other websites, we are only paid if there is an affiliate program such as Avantlink, Impact, Amazon and eBay and only if you purchase something. If you’d like to directly donate to help fund our continued report, please visit our donations page.

---

Works cited

1. HUNTING – Office of Outdoor Recreation, accessed September 8, 2025, https://outdoorrecreation.wi.gov/Documents/Research%20Library%20Page%20files/US%20-%20Demographics%20%26%20Participation/2023_OIA_Special%20Report%20on%20Hunting.pdf
2. 10 Greatest Deer Hunting Cartridges – The Mossberg Journal, accessed September 8, 2025, https://resources.mossberg.com/journal/10-greatest-deer-hunting-cartridges
3. Best Caliber for Deer Hunting | Mossy Oak, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.mossyoak.com/our-obsession/blogs/deer/best-caliber-for-deer-hunting
4. Popular Calibers for Hunting Deer | Mossy Oak, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.mossyoak.com/our-obsession/blogs/hunting/popular-calibers-for-hunting-deer
5. 10 Best Hunting Cartridges: Your List Vs Mine – YouTube, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Og9DITHIlKw
6. Top 10 Hunting Cartridges of the Past 10 Years | An Official Journal …, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.americanhunter.org/content/top-10-hunting-cartridges-of-the-past-10-years/
7. The Top 10 Rifle Cartridges for North American Big Game – Petersen’s Hunting, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.petersenshunting.com/editorial/americas-top-10-big-game-cartridges/272339
8. Top 15 Most Popular Rifle Cartridges (2025 Edition) – Backfire.TV, accessed September 8, 2025, https://backfire.tv/popular-cartridges/
9. What’s the Best Cartridge for Deer Hunting? – Game & Fish, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.gameandfishmag.com/editorial/best-cartridge-hunting-deer/526727
10. The Best Deer Calibers Ever, accessed September 8, 2025, https://nadeerhunter.com/best-deer-caliber/
11. Buy Core-Lokt 30-06 Springfield Ammo | 150 Grain, 2910 FPS – Remington, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.remington.com/rifle/shop-by-caliber/shop-all-calibers/29-27826.html
12. Top 10 Classic Deer Bullets – Born Hunting, accessed September 8, 2025, https://bornhunting.com/top-10-classic-deer-bullets/
13. Remington .30-06 Springfield Core-Lokt 150gr PSP Ammo – Black Basin Outdoors, accessed September 8, 2025, https://blackbasin.com/remington-27826-core-lokt-pointed-soft-point-150-grain-30-06-springfield/
14. The Greatest Whitetail Cartridge of All Time | MeatEater Wired To Hunt, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.themeateater.com/wired-to-hunt/general/the-greatest-whitetail-cartridge-of-all-time
15. If You Can Only Pick One Big Game Hunting Cartridge, Pick This One | MeatEater Hunting, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.themeateater.com/hunt/firearm-hunting/if-you-can-only-pick-one-big-game-hunting-cartridge-pick-this-one
16. The 5 Best Deer Hunting Calibers | MeatEater Wired To Hunt, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.themeateater.com/wired-to-hunt/whitetail-hunting-gear/5-best-whitetail-cartridges
17. Hardware Review: Federal Fusion Tipped Ammunition | An Official Journal Of The NRA, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.americanhunter.org/content/hardware-review-federal-fusion-tipped-ammunition/
18. Expert reviews of Federal Fusion Rifle 308 Win 150 Grain | ExpertVoice, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.expertvoice.com/product/federal-fusion-rifle-308-win-150-grain/356661?p=F308FS1
19. Ammo test: Federal Fusion .308 Winchester 150gr – Rifle Shooter, accessed September 8, 2025, https://rifle-shooter.com/rifles/ammo-test-federal-fusion-308-winchester-150gr/
20. The Ten Best Deer Cartridges: My List vs Yours – YouTube, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQvauwEStCc
21. 270 Win 140 gr SST® Superformance® ‑ Hornady Manufacturing, Inc, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.hornady.com/ammunition/rifle/270-win-140-gr-sst-superformance#!/
22. Hornady .270 Win Superformance 140gr SST Ammo – Black Basin Outdoors, accessed September 8, 2025, https://blackbasin.com/hornady-80563-superformance-super-shock-tip-140-grain-270-winchester/
23. Hornady Superformance .270 Winchester 130 Grain SST Centerfire Rifle Ammo, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.basspro.com/p/hornady-superformance-270-winchester-130-grain-sst-centerfire-rifle-ammo
24. Hornady sst | The Stalking Directory, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.thestalkingdirectory.co.uk/threads/hornady-sst.268050/
25. Best Caliber for Deer Hunting: Settling the Whitetail Cartridge Debate – Reddit, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Hunting/comments/xp5yjx/best_caliber_for_deer_hunting_settling_the/
26. Best Deer Bullet for .243 Win (And Where to Put It) – Camo Crew, accessed September 8, 2025, https://camocrew.com/best-deer-bullet-for-243-win/
27. Power-Shok – Federal Premium, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.federalpremium.com/rifle/power-shok/
28. Federal Power Shok | The Stalking Directory, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.thestalkingdirectory.co.uk/threads/federal-power-shok.44494/
29. Best Caliber for Deer Hunting Chosen by the Experts at Ammo.com, accessed September 8, 2025, https://ammo.com/best/caliber-for-deer-hunting
30. Hornady LeveRevolution 30-30 Review: Tested and Approved – Ammo.com, accessed September 8, 2025, https://ammo.com/ammo-review/hornady-leverevolution-30-30-review
31. 30‑30 Win 160 gr FTX® LEVERevolution® ‑ Hornady Manufacturing, Inc, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.hornady.com/ammunition/rifle/30-30-win-160-gr-ftx-leverevolution#!/
32. Any real difference for a 30-30 hornady leverevolution vs standard rounds at 100yrds, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.canadiangunnutz.com/forum/threads/any-real-difference-for-a-30-30-hornady-leverevolution-vs-standard-rounds-at-100yrds.1261959/
33. Review: Hornady ELD-X Precision Hunter Ammo – RifleShooter, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.rifleshootermag.com/editorial/review-hornady-eld-x-precision-hunter-ammo/83753
34. Review: Hornady Precision Hunter Ammunition | An Official Journal Of The NRA, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.americanhunter.org/content/review-hornady-precision-hunter-ammunition/
35. 7mm-08 Remington as a Cradle to Grave Hunting Cartridge? – RifleShooter, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.rifleshootermag.com/editorial/7mm08-remington-great-hunting-cartridge/524088
36. How to Pick the Best PRC Caliber For You? – Petersen’s Hunting, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.petersenshunting.com/editorial/pick-your-prc-poison/488612
37. 6.5 PRC 143 gr ELD‑X® Precision Hunter® ‑ Hornady Manufacturing, Inc, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.hornady.com/ammunition/rifle/6.5-prc-143-gr-eld-x-precision-hunter#!/
38. 6 5 PRC Gel Test: Barnes, Hornady, & Nosler Loads Evaluated! – YouTube, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qxkvm-aY9YU
39. Best 7mm PRC Ammo From Hunting to Long-Range Shots, accessed September 8, 2025, https://ammo.com/best/best-7mm-prc-ammo
40. The 7 PRC: Best of the PRC Cartridges – Shooting Times, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.shootingtimes.com/editorial/7prc-best-prc-cartridges/522239
41. 7mm PRC Ballistics – Velocity, Energy & Trajectory Data – The Shooter’s Log, accessed September 8, 2025, https://blog.cheaperthandirt.com/7mm-prc-ballistics/
42. 7mm PRC 175 gr ELD‑X® Precision Hunter® ‑ Hornady Manufacturing, Inc, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.hornady.com/ammunition/rifle/7mm-prc-175-gr-eld-x-precision-hunter#!/
43. HORNADY 7MM PRC 175 ELD-X – G.A. Precision, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.gaprecision.net/hornady-7mm-prc-175-eld-x.html
44. 7mm-08 Remington – Wikipedia, accessed September 8, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7mm-08_Remington
45. 7mm-08 Remington – Terminal Ballistics Research, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.ballisticstudies.com/Knowledgebase/7mm-08+Remington.html
46. Buy Core-Lokt 7mm-08 Rem Ammo | 140 Grain, 2860 FPS – Remington, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.remington.com/rifle/shop-by-caliber/shop-all-calibers/29-21337.html
47. Remington factory 140 core lokts 7mm08 OAL??? – Shooters’ Forum, accessed September 8, 2025, https://forum.accurateshooter.com/threads/remington-factory-140-core-lokts-7mm08-oal.3793660/
48. Remington Ammunition 25-06 100GR CORE LOKT PSP 20 RD – Jay’s Sporting Goods, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.jayssportinggoods.com/remington-ammunition/25-06-100gr-core-lokt-psp-20-rd-60143
49. Buy Core-Lokt 25-06 Rem Ammo | 100 Grain, 3230 FPS – Remington, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.remington.com/rifle/shop-by-caliber/shop-all-calibers/29-21507.html
50. 7mm Rem Mag 162 gr SST® Superformance® ‑ Hornady Manufacturing, Inc, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.hornady.com/ammunition/rifle/7mm-rem-mag-162-gr-sst-superformance#!/
51. Hornady Superformance 7mm Remington Mag Ammo 162 Grain Hornady SST – MidwayUSA, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.midwayusa.com/product/1001702013
52. Hornady Superformance 7mm Remington Magnum 162 Grain SST Centerfire Rifle Ammo, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.cabelas.com/p/hornady-superformance-7mm-remington-magnum-162-grain-sst-centerfire-rifle-ammo
53. Remington Core-Lokt 300 Winchester Mag Ammo 180 Grain Jacketed Soft – MidwayUSA, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.midwayusa.com/product/1001785027
54. Remington Ammunition 300 WIN MAG 180GR CORE LOKT PSP – Jay’s Sporting Goods, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.jayssportinggoods.com/remington-ammunition/300-win-mag-180gr-core-lokt-psp-60168
55. Buy Core-Lokt 300 Win Mag Ammo | 180 Grain, 2960 FPS – Remington, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.remington.com/rifle/shop-by-caliber/shop-all-calibers/29-29497.html
56. Winchester .350 Legend Ammo Review – Shooting Times, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.shootingtimes.com/editorial/winchester-350-legend-ammo-review/370877
57. What Is the Best 350 Legend Ammo? (Accurate and Affordable), accessed September 8, 2025, https://ammo.com/best/best-350-legend-ammo
58. 350 Legend, 150 Grain – Rifle – Winchester Ammunition, accessed September 8, 2025, https://winchester.com/Products/Ammunition/Rifle/Deer-Season-XP/X350DS
59. Review: Winchester Deer Season XP | Field & Stream, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.fieldandstream.com/outdoor-gear/guns/ammo/rifle-ammo/review-winchester-deer-season-xp
60. 450 Bushmaster 250 gr FTX® Hornady BLACK, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.hornady.com/ammunition/rifle/450-bushmaster-250-gr-ftx-black#!/
61. 45 Cal .452 250 gr FTX® (450 Bushmaster) ‑ Hornady Manufacturing, Inc, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.hornady.com/bullets/rifle/45-cal-452-250-gr-ftx-450-bushmaster#!/#dealer-map
62. Hornady Black .450 Bushmaster 250gr FTX Ammo, accessed September 8, 2025, https://blackbasin.com/hornady-82246-black-flex-tip-expanding-250-grain-450-bushmaster/
63. Premier AccuTip Sabot Slug – Remington, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.remington.com/premier-accutip-sabot-slug.html
64. Remington Premier AccuTip Sabot Slug 12ga 3″ 385gr | Clinton Sporting Goods, accessed September 8, 2025, https://clintonsporting.com/product/remington-premier-accutip-sabot-slug-12-ga-3-385-grain/
65. Accutip Sabot Slug, 12 Gauge, 385 Grain, 2-3/4 in, 1850 fps – Remington, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.remington.com/shotshell/accutip-sabot-slug/29-20727.html
66. Accutip Sabot Slug 20 Gauge 260 Grain 1900 Muzzle Velocity – Guidefitter, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.guidefitter.com/Remington/shop/accutip-sabot-slug-20-gauge-260-grain-1900-muzzle-velocity
67. Remington Premier AccuTip Bonded Sabot Slugs | Cabela’s, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.cabelas.com/p/remington-premier-accutip-bonded-sabot-slugs
68. Customer Reviews for Remington Premier Accutip 20 Ga. 2 3/4″ 260 Grain Sabot Slug 5rd box – Buds Gun Shop, accessed September 8, 2025, https://www.budsgunshop.com/product_reviews.php/products_id/58364/page/1
69. The BEST deer cartridge! | Nosler Reloading Forum, accessed September 8, 2025, https://forum.nosler.com/threads/the-best-deer-cartridge.32835/