Analytics and Reports, Shotgun Analytics

Turkish SPAS-12 Clones: Value vs. Authenticity

Executive Summary

The small arms market is currently witnessing a significant pivot toward nostalgia-driven engineering, specifically targeting the void left by the cessation of the Franchi SPAS-12 (Special Purpose Automatic Shotgun). For over two decades, the SPAS-12 has existed primarily as a collector’s icon, with secondary market prices ascending to nearly $7,000 for pristine examples due to its unique dual-mode gas/pump action and cinematic ubiquity.1 This demand has catalyzed a new generation of Turkish-manufactured clones, most notably the Bronco Arms TAC SX (also known as the SPS 12 F) and various “homage” models like the JTS M12 PT2 and the Military Armament Corporation (MAC) series.2

This report examines the engineering quality, import compliance, and consumer sentiment surrounding these new entrants. While the Bronco TAC SX provides a visually faithful representation of the original, it incorporates modern gas-operated systems that lack parts compatibility with the Italian original, instead opting for a Benelli-style internal architecture.2 Buyer sentiment remains cautious; while the “cool factor” is undeniable for recreational users and “cloners,” the long-term reliability of Turkish metallurgy and the historical lack of local parts support present significant hurdles.4

Comparative analysis suggests that for professional or defensive applications, the Benelli M3 remains the superior dual-mode platform, offering a more refined inertia-driven system and established logistical support.6 However, for the specific use case of cinematic collecting and low-cost recreation, the modern clones offer a value proposition that the inflated vintage market cannot match. It is recommended that potential buyers prioritize importers with established warranty infrastructures, such as SDS Imports, and expect a rigorous break-in period involving high-velocity ammunition to ensure reliable cycling.8

1. The Legacy and Engineering Complexity of the Franchi SPAS-12

The original Franchi SPAS-12 was conceived in 1972 as a dedicated combat shotgun, designed to bridge the gap between the rapid firepower of a semi-automatic and the versatility of a pump action capable of cycling low-pressure specialty munitions.10 Its engineering was defined by a massive, milled steel receiver and a unique short-stroke gas piston system located beneath the barrel. This dual-mode functionality was toggled via a button on the bottom of the forend, which allowed the operator to switch between gas-operated semi-auto for standard buckshot and pump-action for less-lethal rounds, such as beanbags or tear gas canisters, which lacked sufficient pressure to cycle the bolt automatically.1

Despite its iconic status, the SPAS-12 was an engineering enigma full of practical failures. Weighing approximately 9.7 pounds unloaded, it was significantly heavier than its contemporaries, leading to fatigue in sustained operations.1 Its manual of arms was notoriously complex, involving multiple safeties and a selector system that could be awkward to manipulate under stress. Furthermore, the semi-automatic mode was susceptible to “limp wristing,” where a shooter’s lack of a rigid brace would absorb enough recoil energy to cause a failure to cycle—a problem exacerbated by the shotgun’s unconventional folding stock and stabilizing hook.1 This hook was intended to allow for one-handed firing by rotating under the forearm, but in practice, it often served more as a carrying handle or a stabilizer for administrative tasks.1

Production of the SPAS-12 ceased in 2000 as Franchi pivoted to the magazine-fed SPAS-15, which corrected some ergonomic deficiencies but never achieved the same cultural footprint.1 The ensuing 25-year production vacuum, combined with US import bans like the 1989 and 1994 “assault weapon” restrictions, transformed the SPAS-12 into a scarce commodity.1 This rarity has driven prices from an original retail of $1,500 in its final year to auction figures exceeding $7,000 today, creating the perfect economic conditions for modern manufacturers to attempt clones.1

2. Market Emergence of Modern Turkish Clones

The vacuum left by Franchi has been filled almost exclusively by the Turkish firearms industry, which has spent the last decade developing a robust manufacturing base for semi-automatic shotguns based on the Benelli M4 (ARGO) and M2 (Inertia) platforms.3 The Bronco Arms TAC SX, unveiled at SHOT Show 2026, represents the most direct attempt to clone the SPAS-12 aesthetic and functionality for the US market.2 Unlike previous “look-alike” models that were merely pump-action guns with a heat shield, the TAC SX is a true dual-mode hybrid.

However, industry analysts note a critical distinction: these are not “clones” in the sense of parts-interchangeable replicas. The Bronco representative at SHOT Show 2026 explicitly stated that there is 0% parts compatibility with the original Franchi SPAS-12.2 Instead, the internal mechanism is a reimagined gas system, likely modified from Bronco’s existing M4-style clones, housed in a receiver shaped to mimic the SPAS-12.2 This approach allows the manufacturer to maintain a lower price point—projected to be under $1,000—compared to the astronomical prices of vintage units.4

Complementing the Bronco model are other budget entries like the JTS M12 PT2. While often branded as the “Spas at home,” the JTS model utilizes an inertia-driven semi-auto system rather than gas, paired with a pump mode.3 This mechanical deviation highlights a trend in the “clone” market where visual fidelity is often prioritized over mechanical accuracy. For the consumer, this creates a confusing landscape where the term “clone” can refer to anything from a 1:1 visual homage to a loosely inspired hybrid.

3. Technical Evaluation: Quality and Engineering Differences

When evaluating the quality of these modern clones, one must look at the shift from Italian steel milling to Turkish aluminum alloy casting and CNC machining. The original SPAS-12 used a heavy steel receiver to handle the stresses of a short-stroke gas system.1 Modern clones, including the Bronco TAC SX and the MAC series, typically utilize 7075-T6 aluminum alloy receivers to save weight and reduce manufacturing costs.5 While this reduces the weight to a more manageable 8.3 pounds, it also alters the recoil impulse and longevity of the receiver under high-round counts.

The Bronco TAC SX introduces modern features that the original lacked, such as a 3-inch chamber (the original was 2.75″ only) and integrated Picatinny rails for optics.2 These are significant upgrades for the modern shooter, as the original SPAS-12 required expensive and rare proprietary mounts for optics.12 Furthermore, the Bronco model uses modern choke systems, whereas many original SPAS-12s had fixed cylinders or used a proprietary external thread system for their famous “duckbill” spreaders.10

Reliability testing of these clones often reveals a stringent “break-in” requirement. Data from the JTS M12 PT2 suggests that out of the box, these guns may struggle with low-brass birdshot, requiring approximately 100 to 300 rounds of high-velocity buckshot to smooth out the action.8 Common failure points include the “lifter lock” button on dual-mode guns, which can trip under the recoil of heavy 3-inch magnum shells, effectively deadening the action.15 This illustrates a fundamental challenge in dual-mode engineering: the complex linkage required to disconnect the semi-auto gas system and engage the pump slide introduces more mechanical variables that can fail.

4. Analysis of Competition: The Benelli M3 and the Semi-Auto Leaders

The closest functional competitor to any SPAS-12 clone is the Benelli M3. Introduced in 1987, the M3 was Benelli’s answer to the SPAS-12, offering the same dual-mode functionality but with the refined, inertia-driven system for which Benelli is famous.1

ModelAction TypeReliability (1-10)Ergonomics (1-10)Market Value (2026)
Franchi SPAS-12Gas / Pump64$5,000 – $7,500
Bronco TAC SXGas / Pump7 (Projected)6$800 – $1,100
Benelli M3Inertia / Pump98$1,900 – $2,200
Beretta 1301Gas (Semi-Only)109$1,600 – $1,800
MAC 1014Gas (Semi-Only)87$400 – $600

As indicated in the performance matrix, the Benelli M3 remains the gold standard for users who truly need a pump-action fallback. Because the M3 uses an inertia system, it has fewer moving parts and is significantly lighter than the gas-operated SPAS-12 clones.7 However, inertia systems are famously picky about ammunition; they require a solid shoulder weld to cycle, meaning they often fail to run when fired from the hip or when heavily loaded with accessories.1

For most buyers, the real competition isn’t another dual-mode shotgun, but modern semi-automatics like the Beretta 1301 or Benelli M4. These guns have largely rendered the “pump mode” obsolete because their gas systems (such as Beretta’s B-LINK or Benelli’s ARGO) are so reliable they can cycle a wide variety of loads, including some less-lethal rounds, without manual intervention.19 The MAC 1014, a Turkish-made Benelli M4 clone, has particularly disrupted the market by offering 90% of the M4’s performance for 25% of the price, further pressuring the value proposition of a $1,000 SPAS-12 clone.5

5. Buyer Sentiment: Nostalgia vs. Practicality

Buyer sentiment regarding SPAS-12 clones is polarized between the “collector/LARP” segment and the “tactical/defensive” segment. For the former, the Bronco TAC SX is a long-awaited miracle. The ability to own a gun that replicates the folding stock and heat shield seen in Jurassic Park for a reasonable price is a compelling draw.14 Sentiment in this group is often summarized by the desire to “LARP as Muldoon” without risking the structural integrity of a rare $7,000 vintage investment.14

Conversely, the tactical community remains highly skeptical. The “Turkshit” stigma—a perception that Turkish shotguns are built with soft metals and poor quality control—is a major hurdle for Bronco and other importers.4 Users on forums often recount “horror stories” of Turkish guns failing after only a few boxes of shells, or importers disappearing and leaving owners with no way to find replacement parts.3 This sentiment is slowly shifting as brands like SDS Imports provide one-year warranties and lifetime service plans, but the skepticism remains a drag on the market.9

Furthermore, there is a “cloner” sentiment that the Bronco TAC SX is not “real” enough. Because the receiver and controls more closely resemble a Benelli than a Franchi, some purists feel the gun is an “uncanny valley” reproduction—looking like a SPAS-12 from a distance but feeling like a generic Turkish semi-auto upon closer inspection.2

6. The Importer’s Challenge: Compliance and Distribution

The path for the Bronco TAC SX and similar clones to reach the US market is fraught with regulatory hurdles. The ATF’s “sporting purpose” test is the primary gatekeeper for imported shotguns. To comply with the 1989 and 1994 restrictions, imported shotguns must typically arrive in a “sporterized” configuration, often with fixed stocks and no pistol grips.2

Information from SHOT Show 2026 indicates that Bronco Arms plans to import the TAC SX with a fixed traditional stock to satisfy these requirements, then sell the iconic folding stock as a separate “accessory”.2 This puts the onus on the buyer to ensure their final configuration remains compliant with Section 922r, which requires that a firearm assembled from imported parts contains no more than 10 specified foreign-made components.8

Distribution also remains a bottleneck. While Bronco Arms has an engaged importer, they had not selected a US-based distributor as of early 2026.2 Without a major distributor like Palmetto State Armory or Atlantic Firearms, the clones may struggle to reach the mass market, remaining niche items sold through small-batch importers with limited support.4

7. Use Cases: Should You Buy a SPAS-12 Clone?

Based on the engineering and market data, the decision to purchase a SPAS-12 clone should be dictated by the user’s specific requirements.

Use Case 1: Recreational Collecting and Nostalgia

Verdict: Recommended For the individual who grew up watching The Terminator or playing Half-Life, the Bronco TAC SX is an excellent purchase. It satisfies the aesthetic requirement at a sustainable price point. The 0% parts compatibility is a non-issue for this user, as the gun is intended for occasional range use rather than duty service. The addition of a 3-inch chamber and Picatinny rails actually makes it a more versatile range toy than the original.2

Use Case 2: Home Defense and Life Safety

Verdict: Not Recommended For defensive purposes, the complexity of a dual-mode shotgun is a liability. Under the physiological stress of a home invasion, the risk of short-stroking the pump or accidentally engaging the wrong safety lever is too high.1 Furthermore, the lack of long-term reliability data on the Bronco gas system makes it a “unknown quantity.” A dedicated semi-automatic like the Beretta 1301 or a proven pump like the Mossberg 590 provides far superior reliability and a simpler manual of arms for the same or less money.6

Use Case 3: Competition and 3-Gun

Verdict: Not Recommended Dual-mode shotguns are generally too heavy and have slower reload cycles than purpose-built competition guns. While the Bronco TAC SX is lighter than the original, it still cannot match the speed and ergonomic refinement of the Rock Island VR80 or the Typhoon Defense X12 in a 3-gun context.25

8. Financial Outlook and Cost of Ownership

The cost of owning a SPAS-12 clone extends beyond the initial purchase price. Prospective owners must account for the “break-in” ammunition costs. Running 200 rounds of high-velocity buckshot at current market prices adds roughly $150 to $200 to the total cost of ownership.8

Furthermore, the resale value of Turkish clones is historically poor compared to Italian or American-made firearms. While an original Franchi SPAS-12 is an appreciating asset, a Turkish clone is a depreciating tool.1 Buyers should view the $1,000 spent on a Bronco TAC SX as “fun money” rather than an investment.

The following table outlines the expected cost of ownership over a three-year period.

Expense CategoryBronco TAC SX (Projected)Benelli M3MAC 1014
Initial Purchase$950$2,100$550
Break-in Ammo$180$50$180
Upgrades/Accessories$300 (Folding Stock)$0$100 (Shell Tube)
Projected Resale$600$1,800$350
Net Cost (3 Years)$830$350$480

9. Conclusion: The Verdict on the SPAS-12 Clone Market

The SPAS-12 clone market represents a fascinating intersection of cinematic nostalgia and modern manufacturing economics. The Bronco Arms TAC SX is a significant achievement in visual reproduction, offering the iconic “look” of the Franchi at a price point that makes it accessible to the average shooter.2 However, the mechanical departure from the original and the inherent risks associated with Turkish manufacturing mean that it is not a “true” replacement for the Italian legend.

From an engineering perspective, these clones are superior to the original SPAS-12 in versatility (3″ chambers and rails) but likely inferior in absolute durability.1 For the buyer, the decision is simple: if you want a piece of movie history to shoot on the weekends, the clone is a viable and fun option. If you want a shotgun for professional use, skip the clones and invest in a Benelli or Beretta.6

As the market matures through 2026, the success of these clones will depend entirely on whether the manufacturers can establish a robust domestic support network. Without spare parts and a reliable warranty process, the Bronco TAC SX risks becoming another “one-hit wonder” in the long history of imported Turkish novelties.

A personal note from the author and not data driven: I owned a real SPAS-12 for quite a few years while they were still in production. It was never very reliable in semi-auto and the pump mode was unrefined and crude feeling. If a modern importer changes action methods, that may be a good thing in terms of helping reliability. Also, the early SPAS models had an unreliable forward rotating safety – if you rotated it, there was a real risk of the trigger being released and the shotgun firing. Bottom line is that while the original SPAS had a cult following due to looks and movies, it was not that great to be perfectly honest. The clones might actually fix some of the issues by moving away from the original SPAS designs. Time will tell.

Appendix: Methodology

This research report was developed using a multi-phase analytical process designed to filter industry hype from technical reality. The primary data was gathered from high-fidelity research snippets covering SHOT Show reports (2024-2026), manufacturer technical catalogs (Bronco Arms, SDS Imports), and active secondary market auction data (Rock Island Auction Company, GunBroker).1

The engineering evaluation involved cross-referencing the claimed operating mechanisms of modern clones (gas vs. inertia) against the known failure points of the original Franchi gas system and competitor inertia systems (Benelli M3). Reliability data was synthesized from longitudinal user testing reports and professional “torture tests” of similar Turkish platforms, specifically focusing on ammunition sensitivity and break-in requirements.8

Buyer sentiment was quantified through a thematic analysis of enthusiast forums and professional community discussions, identifying core anxieties around Turkish manufacturing and “cloner” expectations.3 Finally, financial and regulatory analysis was conducted by reviewing current ATF import guidelines and secondary market price trends to provide a comprehensive cost-of-ownership projection for the end-user.1

If you find this post useful, please share the link on Facebook, with your friends, etc. Your support is much appreciated and if you have any feedback, please email me at in**@*********ps.com. Please note that for links to other websites, we are only paid if there is an affiliate program such as Avantlink, Impact, Amazon and eBay and only if you purchase something. If you’d like to directly contribute towards our continued reporting, please visit our funding page.

Sources Used

  1. The SPAS 12 Shotgun – Rock Island Auction, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.rockislandauction.com/riac-blog/spas-12-shotgun
  2. [SHOT 2026] Bronco Arms SPAS12 “Clone” | thefirearmblog.com, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/shot-2026-bronco-arms-spas12-clone-44825461
  3. Best Turkish Shotgun Manufactures? – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/1nu0fxf/best_turkish_shotgun_manufactures/
  4. Spas 12 clone from Bronco Arms. : r/ForgottenWeapons – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/ForgottenWeapons/comments/1qjiz8q/spas_12_clone_from_bronco_arms/
  5. Is the mac 1014 really that bad? : r/tacticalgear – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/tacticalgear/comments/1mja0jc/is_the_mac_1014_really_that_bad/
  6. Franchi Spas 12 vs benelli semi auto which one better for long lasting use and reliability during zombie apocalypse : r/ZombieSurvivalTactics – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/ZombieSurvivalTactics/comments/1jr6ror/franchi_spas_12_vs_benelli_semi_auto_which_one/
  7. Which to choose? : r/Shotguns – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/1qok1e9/which_to_choose/
  8. First gun : r/Shotguns – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/1oyi40k/first_gun/
  9. SDS Arms: Shotguns & Firearms for Sale | Gun Accessories & Parts, accessed January 30, 2026, https://sdsarms.com/
  10. Franchi SPAS-12 – Wikipedia, accessed January 30, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franchi_SPAS-12
  11. Franchi SPAS-12 – Gun Wiki | Fandom, accessed January 30, 2026, https://guns.fandom.com/wiki/Franchi_SPAS-12
  12. For Sale- Franchi SPAS 12 – Benelli, accessed January 30, 2026, https://forums.benelliusa.com/topic/25590-for-sale-franchi-spas-12/
  13. The Ruthless SPAS 12 Special Purpose Automatic Shotgun – Firearms News, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.firearmsnews.com/editorial/ruthless-spas-12-special-purpose-automatic-shotgun/516560
  14. The Best Shotguns of SHOT Show 2025 – GAT Daily (Guns Ammo …, accessed January 30, 2026, https://gatdaily.com/articles/the-best-shotguns-of-shot-show-2025/
  15. Testing The Worlds Cheapest Dual Action Shotgun: JTS M12 PT2 The Spas 12 At Home, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Io2wCp3PsmM
  16. Untitled – BRONCO ARMS, accessed January 30, 2026, https://broncoarms.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Bronco-Katalog.pdf
  17. SPAS-12 vs. Benelli M3/M4 : r/guns – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/w3ba0u/spas12_vs_benelli_m3m4/
  18. Benelli M4 or Beretta 1301/A300 Ultima Patrol? Why one versus the other?, accessed January 30, 2026, https://forums.benelliusa.com/topic/27524-benelli-m4-or-beretta-1301a300-ultima-patrol-why-one-versus-the-other/
  19. What is the BEST Benelli M4 Clone? : r/Shotguns – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/u0yaww/what_is_the_best_benelli_m4_clone/
  20. Is there a good “knock off” Spas-12? : r/Firearms – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Firearms/comments/8dp10k/is_there_a_good_knock_off_spas12/
  21. [Shotgun] Military Armament Corporation MAC 2(1014/Turknelli) 12-Gauge Semi-Auto Shotgun – Wood Stock(pistol grip+adjustable stock version available as well) – $329.99 – Free Shipping : r/gundeals – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/gundeals/comments/1nvnyyl/shotgun_military_armament_corporation_mac/
  22. Sulun SPAS-12 – SPAS repro availability for import | Canadian Gun …, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.canadiangunnutz.com/forum/threads/sulun-spas-12-%E2%80%93-spas-repro-availability-for-import.2529622/
  23. Haven’t heard anybody talk about this will this Bronco Spas 12 clone be legal soon?, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/CAguns/comments/1nkttub/havent_heard_anybody_talk_about_this_will_this/
  24. Best Semi-Auto Shotguns [2025 Buyer’s Guide] – Recoil Magazine, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.recoilweb.com/best-semi-auto-shotguns-175336.html
  25. The Best AR-12 Shotguns: Modern Firepower From Tactical to Sport | American Firearms, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.americanfirearms.org/best-ar12-shotguns/
  26. Actually good Turkish shotguns? – Reddit, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/1ig5ek3/actually_good_turkish_shotguns/
  27. MAC 2 Tactical Wood – 12GA Semi-Auto Shotgun – Military Armament Corporation, accessed January 30, 2026, https://milarmamentcorp.com/mac-2-tactical-wood/
  28. SPAS 12 for Sale | Buy Online at GunBroker, accessed January 30, 2026, https://www.gunbroker.com/spas-12/search?keywords=spas%2012&s=f&cats=980